Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1031
IMPLEMENTATION OF STRETCHING EXERCISE WITH
ERGONOMIC BASED HEALTH EDUCATION APPROACH
TO REDUCE MUSCULOSKELETAL COMPLAINTS AND
FATIGUE IN ORANGE FARMERS IN BAYUNGGEDE
VILLAGE
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati
1
, I Made Krisna Dinata
2
, Dewa Putu Sutjna
3
, Luh Made
Indah Sri Handari Adiputra
4
, Putu Adiartha Griadhi
5
1,2,4)
Master of Work Physiology Ergonomics Postgraduate Udayana University, Denpasar, Indonesia
3,5)
Department of Physiology, Faculty of Medicine, Udayana University, Denpasar, Indonesia
luhdwierna@gmail.com
1
, krisnadinata@unud.ac.id
2
, idp_sucana@yahoo.com
3
, handari_adiputra@unud.ac.id
4
,
adiartha.griadhi@unud.ac.id
5
KEYWORDS
Ergonomics, Stretching
Exercise, Education,
Musculoskeletal
Complaints, Fatigue of
Citrus Farmers
ABSTRACT
Agricultural activities such as hoeing, cleaning grass, and fertilizing are activities
that affect the work attitude of farmers. The intervention was in the form of giving
Stretching Exercises with an ergonomics-based health education approach. This
study aims to determine the provision of Stretching Exercises with an ergonomics-
based health education approach to reduce musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue
in citrus farmers in Bayunggede village. This research is an experimental study,
using the same subject design with a pattern (Treatment by subject Design). This
study involved 13 research samples selected at simple random. Musculoskeletal
complaints were measured using a Nordic Body Map questionnaire on 4 Likert
scales, work fatigue was measured using a 30-item rating scale. Measurements
were taken before and after work in Period 1 and Period 2 for 3 weeks. Analysis
of the data obtained begins with descriptive analysis and normality test of data
with Shapiro-Wilk. Furthermore, the data with normal distribution were analyzed
using paired t-test at a significance level of 5%. The results showed a significant
difference (p<0.05) in musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue in Period I and
Period II. By doing Stretching Exercises with an ergonomics-based health
education approach, it can reduce musculoskeletal complaints by 29.53% and
work fatigue by 26.97%. It can be concluded that there is a decrease in
musculoskeletal complaints and work fatigue after doing Stretching Exercises
with an ergonomics-based health education approach. Thus, it can be suggested to
citrus farmers to manage time and work breaks well and regularly stretch.
INTRODUCTION
Indonesia is wrong one country agrarian which part big people with eyes livelihood as
a farmer. Indonesia is also known as a reliable producer of various agricultural products. The
majority of people in Indonesia are people who work in agriculture, especially people who
are or live in rural areas . One of the provinces in Indonesia that mostly work as farmers is
the province of Bali , which is a horticultural area . Orange is one of the horticultural crops
which has been developed on area agriculture in Province Bali. M majority farmer orange in
Bali come from Bangli Regency, Buleleng Regency, and Gianyar Regency (Alitawan &
Sutrisna, 2017) . One of the largest local citrus producers is in Bayung Gede Village,
Kintamani District, Bangli Regency (Aluhariandu et al ., 2016) .
Volume 3, Number 11, September 2022
e-ISSN: 2797-6068 and p-ISSN: 2777-0915
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1032
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
Based on the Central Statistics Agency (2017) Bayung Gede Village is a village with
an area of 10.24 km, this village is located about 55 km from the Denpasar sea and about 35
km north of Bangli. There are 2 routes to reach Bayung Gede Village, either from Payangan -
Kintamani or Bangli - Kintamani. The environmental status of Bangli district (2015) states
that the basic physical condition of the area based on topography, geology, Bayung Gede
village is at an altitude of about 800-900 M above sea level which causes Bayung Gede
Village to have cool air with the highest peak point being the Writing Peak. Regional
conditions vary between sub-districts and are generally in plain (0-2%), sloping (2-15%),
wavy (15-30%), steep (30-40%) and very steep (>40%) conditions.). Relatively flat
conditions are found at the foot of Mount Batur, and on average wavy in the Kintamani
District.
Orange farmers need a lot of energy large enough to manage agricultural land.
Agricultural activities such as hoeing, planting, clearing weeds, fertilizing, spraying pests,
and harvesting are activities which affect the working attitude of farmers. Traditionally, citrus
farmers still apply manual work process without being assisted by modern tools (Malonda et
al ., 2016) . Based on preliminary studies in field , agricultural activities carried out farmer
Citrus fruits in Bayung Gede Village such as hoeing, spraying pesticides, and cleaning weeds
are routine jobs, while pruning oranges, fertilizing and picking oranges are seasonal jobs.
From the results of direct interviews with some citrus farmers, the physical activity or task
they do is quite heavy. Hoeing, cleaning and transporting weeds with a less ergonomic
posture and farmers usually bring grass that has been cleaned by carrying or carrying by hand
manually has a high risk. The type of activity of citrus farmers that poses a high risk to health
is when hoeing, spraying pesticides and cleaning weeds, the attitude of farmers who always
bend over and work for a long time will cause musculoskeletal complaints and work fatigue.
The activities of citrus farmers in Bayung Gede Village are carried out by female and
male workers. The work of citrus farmers in the garden is usually done by 2 to 4 farmers.
However, the extent of agricultural land causes a heavy workload and takes a long time to
complete. The duration of work is 8 hours of work in a day and erratic rest hours. The
activities of hoeing, clearing weeds and spraying pesticides, which often involve bending
down and bending over, cause a lot of muscle complaints after work. Heavy workloads such
as repeatedly carrying 10 to 30 kg of heavy fertilizer, and spraying with a 15-20 kg heavy
lifting machine. The placement of water reservoirs that are far away and the unavailability of
automatic faucets make farmers have to draw when spraying, causing an increase in the
workload of citrus farmers in addition to carrying the spray machine for a long time. Farming
is one of the jobs that uses a lot of muscle power and has a high risk of experiencing
musculoskeletal complaints and work fatigue, farmers can be said to be workers who have a
high risk of muscle injury caused by doing work still manually so that many workers' body
movements are still carried out in the wrong position and attitude and are not in accordance
with the limits of body functions (Utami et al . , 2017) .
Based on a preliminary study of the results of measurements of 10 citrus farmers, on
average, they complained of moderate fatigue and musculoskeletal complaints with a score of
58 to 86 with a score of pain. Of the 10 farmers in the preliminary study, on average, the
most complained of pain in the neck, shoulders, upper arms, waist and buttocks caused by
static movements, large loads and carried out for long periods of time and erratic rest hours.
Complaint prevalence musculoskeletal problems in farmers in a study in Sweden 47% had
complaints in the lower back, 56% in the neck and shoulders, 46% on the knee, (Aluhariandu
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1033
et al . , 2016) . While research in Nigeria, on average, complains about the lower waist about
72% due to repetitive work, excessive use of energy, static working position, poor working
position, mechanical stress, vibration and temperature extreme in the place work (Faujiyah,
2020) .
The prevalence of fatigue in farmers in the study of workload and work fatigue in
Minahasa district has the largest prevalence, namely moderate fatigue as many as 53 people
(62.3%), fatigue caused by workload and long working time > 8 hours of work in a day, then
the work environment , as well as monotonous work for a long time will trigger work fatigue
(Wurarah et al. , 2020) . Farmer activities that are monotonous, long work intensity, mental,
physical work resistance, non-ergonomic work environment, tension, health and nutritional
disorders, and sleep disorders will trigger work fatigue (Ramdan, 2018) .
Research Agrawal, et al. (2018) stated that agricultural work should avoid bad work
positions, take breaks between work hours, avoid long working hours to reduce occupational
diseases, implement prevention strategies such as reducing injuries and overwork.
Agricultural activities will also result in farmers experiencing stress, muscle tension and
work-related musculoskeletal disorders that result in several diseases and disabilities (Ghosh
et al. , 2018) .
Other studies also show that farmers have the wrong work attitude due to a lack of knowledge
of farmers about good and correct work attitudes (Lestari, 2010) . Knowledge of farmers in carrying
out farming activities is also very influential on the activities carried out at work and the work risks
caused such as occupational health, work safety, work-related injuries, and work-related fatigue
(Murtiningrum & Silamat, 2019) . The work of citrus farmers with a heavy workload and the use
of excessive muscle power, long working hours and monotonous activities causes the use of
excessive muscle, tendon, and joint power which will increase pressure on nerves and will
cause fatigue to workers (Damantalm et al., 2018) .
To overcome the problems and improve the health quality of farmers, intervention or
ergonomics application is needed. Research needs to be done by combining stretching
exercise with an ergonomics-based health education approach where stretching exercise is
believed to reduce musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue. Giving stretching exercises is
able to overcome musculoskeletal complaints, increase morale, increase blood circulation,
improve physical function, and increase muscle flexibility so that it will reduce muscle injury
and will certainly reduce musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue (Syafrianto, KH, & Zulfa,
2019) .
In previous studies, there were research gaps identified regarding the effects of
stretching exercise and work modification on musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue. In
previous studies, by modifying work without doing stretching exercises , there were no
significant changes in musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue . While giving regular
stretching exercises, it turns out that stretching exercises are effective in reducing
musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue (Shariat et al., 2018) .
Health Promotion Program or health promotion in the workplace, one of the
strategies that can be done for an ergonomics-based health education approach and increase
work productivity. By promoting health to farmers, it will maintain balance and physical,
mental, social elements and will increase health knowledge related to habits related to good
physical condition, energy, and vitality (Cancelliere, Cassidy, Ammendolia, & Côté, 2011) .
The scope of health promotion in the workplace is also very broad, covering the physical,
psychosocial aspects of workers, the workplace, good rest periods, use of work equipment
and the work environment (Pereira et al., 2019) .
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1034
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
METHOD RESEARCH
This study aims to determine musculoskeletal complaints and levels of fatigue before
and after working for citrus farmers in Bayunggede. This research is an experimental study,
using the same subject design with a pattern (Treatment by subject Design). This study
involved 13 research samples selected at simple random. Musculoskeletal complaints were
measured using a Nordic Body Map questionnaire on 4 Likert scales, work fatigue was
measured using a 30 item rating scale. Measurements were taken before and after work in
Period 1 and Period 2 for 3 weeks.
The independent variable in this study is work attitudes that are not ergonomic. The
dependent variable is (a) musculoskeletal complaints, (b) the level of fatigue. The data
obtained in this study (a) were analyzed descriptively by looking for the mean and standard
deviation or standard deviation, (b) normality test of musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue
were analyzed by Shapiro-wilk test, and (c) data of musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue
were analyzed by paired t-test at a significance level of 5%.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results of the descriptive test of the characteristics of the citrus farmers who are the
research subjects can be seen in table 1 as follows:
Table 1. Subject Characteristics Data on Farmers
Variable
Average±SB
Age (years)
47.62±9.605
Gender
1.46±0.51
Weight (kg)
54.77±10.19
Height (cm)
160.31±4.76
Body mass index
21.35±4.28
Work Experience (years)
24.62±6.28
Based on Table 1, the number of research subjects was 13 farmers consisting of 7 men
and 6 women. Farmers' activities are very diverse, such as hoeing, cleaning weeds, picking
oranges, fertilizing, pruning oranges and other activities. However, in this study, farmers only
carried out several activities or jobs such as hoeing, cleaning weeds, and fertilizing citrus.
The results of the descriptive analysis of the data on the characteristics of the subject include
variables of age, gender, weight, height, body mass index and work experience. Based on the
results of data calculations, the average body mass index of the subject was 21.35±4.283, the
average was included in the ideal category.
The working environment conditions measured in this research location were the
environmental conditions before and when the farmers worked including ambient
temperature, humidity, light intensity, noise and wind speed. The data for measuring
environmental conditions in the morning before the farmers work in Period 1 can be seen in
Table 2. While the data for measuring the conditions of the working environment in the
afternoon after the farmers work in Period 2 can be seen in Table 2.
Table 2 Working Environment Conditions (Before Farmers Work)
Period 1 Pre
Period 2 Pre
Score
Parameter
Average±SB
Average±SB
p
Dry Temperature ( C)
20.10±0.36
20.82±0.33
0.153
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1035
Humidity (%)
66.89±1.70
66.42±1.69
0.396
Intensity
Light (Lux
1624±75.87
1644±84.36
0.352
Noise (dB)
38,20±1.19
38.33±1.38
0.815
Wind velocity
0.73±0.19
0.67±0.09
0.275
Based on Table 2, it can be seen that the results of the significance test on environmental
temperature, environmental humidity, environmental light intensity, environmental noise, and
wind speed in the work environment did not have a significant difference between Period 1
before the farmer worked and Period 2 before the farmer worked. This shows that both
periods have the same environmental characteristics.
Table 3 Working Environment Conditions (After Farmers Work)
Period 1 Post
Period 2 Post
Score
Parameter
Average±SB
Average±SB
p
Dry Temperature ( C)
24.94±0.99
25.23±2.11
0.550
Humidity (%)
67.73±2.16
67.47±1.78
0.310
Intensity
Light (Lux
1658±64.69
1641±86.40
0.248
Noise (dB)
39.80±2.53
40.37±3.25
0.168
Wind velocity
0.73±0.225
0.70±0.1414
0.133
Based on Table 3, it can be seen that the test results of the significance of environmental
temperature, humidity, light intensity, noise, and wind speed did not have a significant
difference between Period 1 after the farmer worked and period 2 after the farmer worked.
This shows that the two periods have the same environmental characteristics.
The results of the comparability test for musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue can be
seen in Table 4. In Table 4. shows the results of the paired t-test to assess the comparability
of data before farmers work between period 1 and period 2 which can affect the effect of the
intervention.
Table 4. Comparability Test Results for Musculoskeletal Complaints and Fatigue
Period 1
Period 2
Score
Variable
Average±SB
Average±SB
P
MSDs Before Work
38,21±3,630
37.65±3.935
0.652
Fatigue Before Work
37.65±3.935
38.67±3.494
0.633
Based on Table 4. it can be explained that there is no significant difference between the
data before farmers work in Period 1 and Period 2 (p> 0.05). This means that there is no
effect of the previous condition in Period 1 that affects changes in the dependent variable. In
addition, the washing out period is sufficient to give the effect of returning to the initial
condition as in the condition before the farmer worked in Period 1. Thus, the intervention
effect occurs purely because of the treatment.
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1036
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
In this study, the research subjects were given an intervention in the form of
implementing stretching exercises and health promotion programs as an ergonomics-based
health education approach. Giving stretching exercises or stretching at work was carried out
for 15 minutes on the sidelines of the break at 13.00 WITA 3 times a week for 3 week.
Meanwhile, the health promotion program is given in the first and last weeks. To determine
the effect of the treatment effect on reducing musculoskeletal complaints and fatigue, a paired
t-test was performed. The results of the analysis can be seen in Table 5.
Table 5. Test of Treatment Effects Using the t-paired . test
Period 1
Period 2
Score
Variable
Average±SB
Average±SB
P
MSDs Post Last Day
58.62±11.6 6
41.31±5.6 1
0.000
Fatigue Post Last Day
6 6 , 79±11.63
48, 78± 7.5 3
0.000
The results of the different tests as shown in Table 5 show that there is an overall
significant difference between musculoskeletal complaints on the last day of week 3 (three)
after farmers work in Period 1 and Period 2 using the paired t-test. The results of the different
tests as shown in Table 5 also show that there is a significant difference in fatigue on the last
day of the third week after farmers work in Period 1 and Period 2 using the paired t-test.
Table 6. Additional Test of Treatment Effects Using the t-paired . test
Period 1
Period 2
Score
Variable
Average±SB
Average±SB
P
MSDs Pre Last Day
45.24±6.8 5
36.85±6.49
0.009
MSDs Post Day One
59.31±9.19
36.16±3.8 1
0.000
MSDs Difference
13.38±11.2 7
5.154±6.8 6
0.010
In this study, it can also be seen in Table 6. test the effect of additional treatment on
musculoskeletal complaints which as an additional test to determine the long-term effect of
giving the intervention by measuring musculoskeletal complaints on the last day of the third
week in Period 1 and Period 2. . And the short-term effect in Period 1 and Period 2 which
was measured on the first day of the first week after working in Period 1 and Period 2. As
well as an additional effect to see muscle endurance formed in Period 1 and Period 2. after
intervening for 3 times in a week for 3 weeks.
Based on the Nordic body map questionnaire measurements in this study, it was found
that the musculoskeletal complaints of citrus farmers decreased between Period 1 and Period
2 by 29.53%. This shows that the intervention provided can improve the health of workers as
seen from the decrease in musculoskeletal complaints of citrus farmers. In Period 1, many
farmers experienced musculoskeletal complaints in the category of pain in the left shoulder,
as many as 8 people (61.54%), right shoulder as many as 4 people (30.77%). In the left upper
arm in the pain category as many as 10 people (61.54%), the right upper arm in the pain
category as many as 11 people (84.62%), then in the waist with pain category (84.62%), and
complaints on the left knee as many as 10 people (76.92%) and right knee as many as 8
people (61.54%). While in Period 2 musculoskeletal complaints after the intervention, there
was a decrease in musculoskeletal complaints in the shoulders by 23.08%, in the upper arms
by 15.38%, then in the waist by 7.69%, and in the knees by 15.38%.
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1037
Figure 1. The Process of Farmers Working Hoeing, Fertilizing, and Cleaning
Grass
In the study of (Daryono et al ., 2016) , static and forced loading can cause blood flow
to be blocked so that the oxygen supply to the muscles is not enough. This situation causes
the accumulation of lactic acid deposits and body heat which in turn causes fatigue in the
skeletal muscles which is felt as a form of muscle pain in workers and triggers
musculoskeletal complaints.
The decrease in musculoskeletal complaints occurred in the final condition or after
work that the average musculoskeletal complaints in Period 1 was 58.70±9,096 while the
average musculoskeletal complaints in Period 2 was 42.41±4,090 . This indicates a decrease
of 29.53%. The decrease is caused because when given active stretching, the muscles can
recover and can build the substances needed for the muscles, in this case the lactic acid left
over from muscle metabolism is recycled and converted into carbon dioxide (CO2), water
and glycogen and protein which will reused for energy. This statement is also in line with
research by Adiatmika et al, ( 2007) , changes in working conditions cause working muscle
cells to have the opportunity to perform optimally. Recovery is required by cells to restore
microtrauma state. Setting the working attitude causes the muscles to contract optimally, so
that the forced labor attitude is reduced. Rest arrangements provide an opportunity for
optimal body recovery. Stretching activities at rest allow the cell to undergo alternate
relaxation contractions. So by doing stretching or stretching exercises will reduce
musculoskeletal complaints.
Short-term effect of intervention on musculoskeletal complaints The effect of
decreasing musculoskeletal complaints that occurred because of the intervention that has
been given in the form of workplace stretching exercise or stretching on the sidelines of
working hours. The intervention or stretching exercises provided have the effect of relaxing
muscles and joints and improving blood circulation around them, thereby reducing muscle
pain and decreasing musculoskeletal complaints (Syafrianto et al., 2019) . This is also in
accordance with research (Smith et al., 2019) that by doing exercise or exercise can trigger
the release of endorphins from the pituitary and hypothalamus which in turn activates
peripheral and central opioid receptors that trigger the endogenous opioid system. With the
activation of opioid receptors which will later produce a strong analgesic effect on the pain
felt in musculoskeletal complaints, during exercise the human body will naturally produce
endogenous opioids. So that when someone does exercise or exercise in the short term, it will
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1038
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
respond to a decrease in musculoskeletal complaints which is a mechanism for reducing pain
when doing exercise or exercise .
Short-term effect of intervention on musculoskeletal complaints The effect of
decreasing musculoskeletal complaints that occurred because of the intervention that has
been given in the form of workplace stretching exercise or stretching on the sidelines of
working hours. The intervention or stretching exercises provided have the effect of relaxing
muscles and joints and improving blood circulation around them, thereby reducing muscle
pain and decreasing musculoskeletal complaints (Syafrianto et al., 2019). This is also in
accordance with research (Smith et al., 2019) that by doing exercise or exercise can trigger
the release of endorphins from the pituitary and hypothalamus which in turn activates
peripheral and central opioid receptors that trigger the endogenous opioid system. With the
activation of opioid receptors which will later produce a strong analgesic effect on the pain
felt in musculoskeletal complaints, during exercise the human body will naturally produce
endogenous opioids. So that when someone does exercise or exercise in the short term, it will
respond to a decrease in musculoskeletal complaints which is a mechanism for reducing pain
when doing exercise or exercise.
Tabita et al. , (2017) research explains the occurrence of long-term effects by doing
stretching exercises on reducing musculoskeletal complaints because stretching exercises
lead to adaptations in both the cardiovascular and musculoskeletal systems that support
increased capacity and overall sports performance. Local adaptations in skeletal muscle, such
as increased mitochondrial biogenesis and capillary density, aid the body's ability to transport
and use oxygen to generate energy and therefore delay the onset of muscle fatigue during
prolonged aerobic performance. This causes a decrease in musculoskeletal complaints in the
long term.
The long-term effect of the intervention on muscle endurance in this study, after doing
stretching exercises or stretching exercises. From the results obtained, there is a significant
difference between the difference between Period 1 and Period 2 of 0.010. In the study of
DeFreitas et al. , (2011) stated that doing stretching exercises for 3-4 weeks significantly
causes skeletal muscle hypertrophy. Muscle hypertrophy can be defined as an increase in
muscle mass due to an increase in the content of contractile proteins and connective tissue.
Muscle hypertrophy can occur due to stimuli such as resistance and stretching exercises for a
long time. So that by doing resistance training and stretching or stretching exercises can
provide muscle endurance when done for a long time, when the exercise has reached 6-7
weeks it will show hypertrophy or a more significant increase in muscle mass so that it will
trigger muscle endurance and increase strength. muscle. In addition, endurance and muscle
strength that occurs when doing stretching exercises are also supported by agonist muscle
activation, neuron stimulation, motor unit synchronization, antagonistic muscle activation,
which are proven to be the main contributors in doing exercises to increase muscle endurance
and strength in the first 3-4 weeks.
Fatigue is a body's protective mechanism to avoid further damage or it can be said as
a body alarm that signals a person to rest immediately. Fatigue can occur characterized by
frequent yawning triggered by monotonous work, fatigue in the form of stiff pain in the back
and shoulders is muscle fatigue.
This means that the treatment or intervention can significantly reduce the fatigue of
citrus farmers. Work fatigue occurs due to muscle cells working statically, menoton and
repetitive. By always carrying out lifting, pressing, and lowering activities for a long period
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1039
of time, namely with a bent standing posture causes farmers to become tired quickly due to
less ergonomic work (Rasna et al., 2015) .
This research is in accordance with Dewi's research, (2018) Giving stretching in the
form of stretching exercises can reduce work fatigue by 26.97%. WSE ( workplace stretching
exercise ) uses the principle of stretching movements in the neck muscle group to the leg
muscle group. In muscles that experience spasm, there will be shortening of muscle fibers
because the myofilaments overlap each other. At the time of stretching with holding for a few
seconds in an elongated muscle position, the muscle fiber structure, especially the
sarcomeres, will stretch because the overlapping myofilaments will decrease and
automatically cause the muscle fiber structure to become elongated. With the lengthening of
the muscle fiber structure , spasm can be reduced and will reduce fatigue that occurs
(Wahyono & Saloko, 2014).
Figure 2. Health Promotion Program as an Ergonomics-Based Health Education
Approach
In this study, conducting health education programs has a very important role for
farmers to provide education that working ergonomically according to their abilities is very
important to improve the health of farmers. In this study, it was found that there was a
decrease in musculoskeletal complaints and work fatigue caused by the intervention. Health
Promotion Program or health promotion in the workplace, one of the ergonomics-based
health education approach strategies that can be done to increase work productivity. By
promoting health to farmers, it will maintain balance and physical, mental, social elements
and will increase health knowledge related to habits related to good physical condition,
energy, and vitality (Cancelliere et al., 2011). The scope of health promotion in the
workplace is also very broad, covering the physical, psychosocial aspects of workers, the
workplace, good rest periods, use of work equipment and the work environment (Pereira et
al., 2019).
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1040
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
(a) Neck and shoulder stretch (b) Shoulder, neck and arm stretch
(c) Shoulder Stretch (d ) Arm and upper back stretch
(e) Shoulder, arm and chest stretch (f) Hand, wrist stretch hands, fingers and forearms
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1041
(g) Upper back stretch (h) Back, shoulder and arm stretch
(i) Stretching the back, hips (j) Stretching the joints of the legs and feet
groin and hamstrings
(k) Lower leg and ankle stretch
Figure 3. Stretching Exercise on Orange Farmers in Bayunggede Village
CONCLUSION
Based on the results of the analysis and discussion that have been described previously, it
can be concluded that the application of Stretching Exercise with an Ergonomics-Based
Health Education Approach reduces musculoskeletal complaints in citrus farmers by 29.53%.
Application of Stretching Exercise with Ergonomics-Based Health Education Approach
reduced musculoskeletal complaints in citrus farmers by 26.97%.
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1042
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
REFERENCES
Adiatmika, I., Manuaba, A., Adiputra, N., & Sutjana, D. (2007). Perbaikan Kondisi
Kerja Dengan Pendekatan Ergonomi Total Menurunkan Keluhan
Muskuloskeletal Dan Kelelahan Serta Meningkatkan Produktivitas Dan
Penghasilan Perajin Pengecatan Logam Di Kediri-Tabanan. Indonesia Journal of
Biomedical Science, 1(3), 112.
Agrawal, Shruti, Ghosh, Jagannath, & Ghosh, Pratiti. (2018). Prevalence of
Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Vegetable Cultivators-a Review. European
Journal of Pharmaceutical and Medical RAgrawal, S., Ghosh, J. and Ghosh, P. (2018)
‘Prevalence of Musculoskeletal Disorders Among Vegetable Cultivators-a Review’,
European Journal of Pharmaceutical and Medical Research, (January), Pp. 144147.
Av, (January), 144147.
Alitawan, Anak Agung Irfan, & Sutrisna, I. Ketut. (2017). Faktor-Faktor yang
Mempengaruhi Pendapatan Petani Jeruk pada Desa Gunung Bau Kecamatan
Kintamani Kabupaten Bangli. E-Jurnal Ekonomi Pembangunan Universitas
Udayana, 6(5), 165350.
Aluhariandu, Vinsensius Efrain, Tariningsih, Dian, & Lestari, Putu Fajar Kartika.
(2016). Analisis usahatani jeruk siam dan faktor faktor yang memepengaruhi
penerimaan petani (studi kasus di desa bayung gede kecamatan kintamani
kabupaten bangli). Agrimeta, 6(12), 7786.
Cancelliere, Carol, Cassidy, J. David, Ammendolia, Carlo, & Côté, Pierre. (2011). Are
workplace health promotion programs effective at improving presenteeism in
workers? A systematic review and best evidence synthesis of the literature.
BMC Public Health, 11(1), 395. https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2458-11-395
Damantalm, Yuhana, Tirtayasa, Ketut, Adiatmika, I. Putu Gede, Manuaba, Ida Bagus
Adnyana, Sutjana, I. Dewa Putu, & Sudiajeng, Lilik. (2018). Pemberian Buah
Pisang, Istirahat Pendek Dan Peregangan Menurunkan Keluhan
Muskuloskeletal, Kelelahan Dan Meningkatkan Produktivitas Pemanen
Pengguna Alat Egrek Perkebunan Kelapa Sawit Pt. Ssd Kalimantan Timur.
Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia (The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic), 4(1), 4756.
https://doi.org/10.24843/jei.2018.v04.i01.p04
Daryono, Dkk. (2016). Redesign of Rakel and Giving Active Stretching Decrease
Workload and Musculoskeletal Complaints and Increase Work Productivity for
Printing Worker on Printing Industry Surya Bali in. Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia,
2(2), 1526.
DeFreitas, Jason M., Beck, Travis W., Stock, Matt S., Dillon, Michael A., & Kasishke,
Paul R. (2011). An examination of the time course of training-induced skeletal
muscle hypertrophy. European Journal of Applied Physiology, 111(11), 27852790.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-011-1905-4
Faujiyah, Firdhani. (2020). Studi prevalensi keluhan muskuloskeletal pada petani
indonesia. Technical Education Development Center, 14(2), 113119.
Ketut laksmi puspa dewi, nyoman adiputra, i made muliarta ketut tirtayasa , i putu
gede adiatmika, i wayan bandem adnyana. (2018). ISSN Print: 1411 ± 951 X,
ISSN Online: 2503-1716. 4(1), 1117.
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah
Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi | http://devotion.greenvest.co.id
1043
Lestari, Dian. (2010). Gambaran Keluhan Muskuloskeletal disorders dan posisi kerja
pada petani jeruk di desa sukoreno kecamatan umbulsari kabupaten jember.
Universitas Jember, 6874.
Luik, Serlien A., Ratu, Jacob M., & Setyobudi, Agus. (2018). Workstation Improvement
Dan Pemberian Stretching Karyawan Pembersihan Injeksi Menurunkan Kebosanan
Workstation Improvement and Application of Stretching Among Employees Injection
Cleaning Reduce Boredom , Musculoskeletal Complaint , and Increase. 4(1), 1827.
Malonda, Christia E., Kawatu, Paul A. .., & Doda, Diana vanda. (2016). Gambaran
Posisi Kerja dan Keluhan Gangguan Musculoskeletal pada Petani Padi di Desa
Kiawa 1 Barat Kecamatan Kawangkoan Utara. PHARMACON, 5(4).
Murtiningrum, Fery, & Silamat, Eddi. (2019). Analisis Usahatani Dan Faktor-Faktor
Yang Mempengaruhi Pendapatan Usahatani Jeruk Gerga Di Desa Rimbo
Pengadang Kecamatan Rimbo Pengadang Kabupaten Lebong. Jurnal Agroqua:
Media Informasi Agronomi Dan Budidaya Perairan, 17(1), 82.
https://doi.org/10.32663/ja.v17i1.651
Pereira, Michelle, Comans, Tracy, Sjøgaard, Gisela, Straker, Leon, Melloh, Markus,
O’leary, Shaun, Chen, Xiaoqi, & Johnston, Venerina. (2019). The impact of
workplace ergonomics and neck-specific exercise versus ergonomics and health
promotion interventions on office worker productivity: A cluster-randomized
trial. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment and Health, 45(1), 4252.
https://doi.org/10.5271/sjweh.3760
Ramdan, Dr. Iwan Muhammad. (2018). Kelelahan Kerja Pada Penenun Tradisional
Sarung Samarinda.
Rasna, I. Made, Tirtayasa, Ketut, & Sutajaya, I. Made. (2015). Modifikasi Gebotan
Berorientasi Ergonomi Meningkatkan Kinerja Petani Wanita Perontok Padi Di
Subak Margaya Desa Pemecutan Kelod Kodya Denpasar. Jurnal Ergonomi
Indonesia (The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic), 1(1).
https://doi.org/10.24843/jei.2015.v01.i01.p05
Shariat, Ardalan, Cleland, Joshua A., Danaee, Mahmoud, Kargarfard, Mehdi,
Sangelaji, Bahram, & Tamrin, Shamsul Bahri Mohd. (2018). Effects of stretching
exercise training and ergonomic modifications on musculoskeletal discomforts
of office workers: a randomized controlled trial. Brazilian Journal of Physical
Therapy, 22(2), 144153. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjpt.2017.09.003
Smith, Benjamin E., Hendrick, Paul, Bateman, Marcus, Holden, Sinead, Littlewood,
Chris, Smith, Toby O., & Logan, Pip. (2019). Musculoskeletal pain and exercise -
Challenging existing paradigms and introducing new. British Journal of Sports
Medicine, 53(14), 907912. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2017-098983
Syafrianto, Eko, K.H, Pramana, & Zulfa, Zulfa. (2019). Pengaruh Workplace
Stretching Exercise (WSE) dan Heat Therapy (Hot Pack) terhadap Keluhan
Muskuloskletal pada Perawat Tahun 2019. Jurnal Ilmiah Universitas Batanghari
Jambi, 19(3), 678. https://doi.org/10.33087/jiubj.v19i3.749
Tabita, Angelin, Adiputra, Nyoman, & Sutarja, I. Nyoman. (2017). Pengaturan
Organisasi Kerja Housekeeping Dengan Pendekatan Ergonomi Dapat
Vol. 3, No. 11, 2022
[ Implementation of Stretching Exercise to Reduce Complaints and
Musculoskeletal Complaints in Orange Farmers in Bayunggede
Village]
1044
http://devotion.greenvest.co.id |Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa
Putu Sutjna, Luh Made Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi
Menurunkan Keluhan Muskuloskeletal, Kelelahan, Dan Mempercepat Waktu
Kerja. Jurnal Ergonomi Indonesia (The Indonesian Journal of Ergonomic), 3(1), 39.
https://doi.org/10.24843/jei.2017.v03.i01.p05
Utami, ucik, Karimuna, Siti Rabbani, & Jufri, Nurnashriana. (2017). Hubungan Lama
Kerja, Sikap Kerja Dan Beban Kerja Dengan Muskuloskeletal Disorders (Msds)
Pada Petani Padi Di Desa Ahuhu Kecamatan Meluhu Kabupaten Konawe
Tahun 2017. J Kesimkesmas Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswaehatan Masyarakat, 2(6), 110.
Wahyono, Yulianto, & Saloko, Erayanti. (2014). Pengaruh Workplace Exercise
Terhadap Keluhan Muskuloskeletal Pada Pkerja Di Bagian Sewing Cv. Cahyo
Nugroho Jati Sukoharjo. Jurnal Terpadu Ilmu Kesehatan, 3(2), 197203.
Wurarah, Mira Lestari, Kawatu, Paul Artur Tennov, & Akili, Rahayu Hasan. (2020).
Hubungan antara Beban Kerja dengan Kelelahan Kerja pada Petani. Indonesian
Journal of Public Health and Community Medicine, 1(2), 610.
Copyright holders:
Luh Dwi Erna Krismawati, I Made Krisna Dinata, Dewa Putu Sutjna, Luh Made
Indah Sri Handari Adiputra , Putu Adiartha Griadhi ( 2022 )
First publication right:
Devotion - Journal of Research and Community Service
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0
International