JOURNAL THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE
DEMOGRAPHIC REVOLUTION TO HUMAN CAPITAL ACHIEVE SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT FOR
COMPANIES IN INDONESIA
Nahason Sitohang
STIE YPBI,
Indonesia
Email: [email protected]
KEYWORDS Demographic Revolution
Perspective, Human Resources, Economic Development, Socially Sustainable Asia
Pacific Perspective, Human-Centered, Sustainable Human Development (SHD). |
ABSTRACT This paper tries to examine
Human Capital from the perspective of Demographic Reformation with various
shifts in various demographic variables in it causing demographic transitions
in various countries in the world each have different characteristics.
Demographic revolution and Human Capital are an inseparable part in terms of
Economic Development, Sustainable Social The Asia Pacific for Human
Development perspective has an orientation to eliminate poverty, poverty for
all mankind, not only that, sustainable development is expected to be able to
provide a better life for efforts meeting the needs of society today and for
the future wisely there for all mankind in a fair and equitable manner.
Sustainable development is an effort to design a new economic, social
development model where Human Capital in sustainable development is a capital
asset for companies/organizations, able to open up new business
opportunities, new jobs for the benefit of an environmentally friendly
demographic bonus. |
INTRODUCTION
The world
today is changing, changing very fast. Knowledge becomes a very temporary
thing. What we know today may no longer apply to tomorrow. The ability to learn
from past experiences and anticipate what will happen in the future is a very
important asset for human survival. A car moving slowly that requires less
vigilance in looking left and right and the distance ahead, compared to a car
traveling very fast. The faster the car goes, the further ahead the driver must
take into account the situation. One of the rapid changes has occurred in
demographic conditions where currently the world, especially Indonesia as one
part of the Asia Pacific countries, is experiencing a very rapid demographic
transition. The situation and conditions of life and human needs are currently
being faced with various changes in shifts in demographic and statistical
variables in all aspects of dynamically fast-moving development. The
demographic revolution led to a demographic transition which also caused
various shifts regarding the birth rate, death rate, and population structure
along with the variables included in it that have changed in various countries
with different characteristics. All of these things have reciprocally
influenced various policies and strategies for implementing development
activities in all aspects of human life. Of course, this is not easy to
understand. The demographic shift that has now caused various shifts.
The
function and role of humans in society, organizations/companies in various
aspects of the development sector, have an effect on supporting efforts to
maintain and maintain human life towards a better, more comfortable way in
various parts of the world.
In connection with
the matters mentioned above, various terms of concepts and policies of economic
development have emerged to the surface. When in the 1970s, developed countries
had introduced mere economic resilience, namely with the term "Sustain
Economics", that is, almost all countries carried out classical economic
development efforts and strategies focused on pursuing the country's economic
growth rate but the results were not very satisfactory for the interests of the
country. all parties. Of course, the role of a country cannot be separated from
the support of economic actors at that time, which in this case were companies
in various product and service sectors, whether they like it or not,
participating in all kinds of efforts to the best of their ability. This was
done to maximize the products and services produced in accordance with the patterns
and policies prevailing at that time. In the situation at that time, the
company was directly expected to be able to maximize the achievement of its
objectives and indirectly would have an impact on the interests of the state.
In fact, the country's economic growth more or less increased at that time
(1980) but the results could only be enjoyed by some companies. Poverty,
injustice, destitution and so on occur in almost all countries in the world,
crime, crime, conflict continues to increase. Furthermore, in 1998, not a few
companies were hit by various problems that finally many companies were unable
to carry out their activities and eventually became static and collapsed.
Then in the
2000s, taking into account various concerns and problems that occurred in
various countries in the world, they introduced a new policy with the term
"Sustainable Economic and Social Development for Human Development from
the Asia-Pacific perspective" (ICDP, 1995), is a new world development policy
in various aspects of the social economy that absolutely must be implemented in
various countries in the world. This is the result of an agreement between
countries in the world and it is hoped that through the result of the agreement
each country is expected to be able to translate or implement it wisely in
their respective countries. Each policy pattern that has been agreed upon at
the international level has a close relationship with the pattern and policy of
implementing economic growth in development within their respective countries,
and will influence the pattern and behavior of domestic economic
actors/companies. This means that each of these policies in each country in the
world will have an impact on all activities and ins and outs of trade that will
be carried out by domestic entrepreneurs and more or less economic actors will
be required to be able to follow the current developments that are happening in
a country, namely the extent to which efforts that need to be made by a company
so that all activities carried out are in accordance with the patterns and
policies that have been determined by the recipient country.
Today's
world economic actors, as well as the community and organizations are now
facing many problems and obstacles originating from within and outside the
country, of course it will greatly disrupt their activities, while
understanding of certain information and understanding abilities are still very
limited.
Another thing that
is very important is that from the observations so far it concerns the success
of the demographic revolution, and the various variables that influence it and
its influence on the shift in the function and role of human resources in
sustainable development which often translates to an understanding of the
emphasis on time issues from one period to the next. , in connection with the
above, this paper will try to study the matter above, to what extent is the
"perspective of the demographic revolution to Human Capital in sustainable
development for companies in Indonesia". It is hoped that this paper can
add knowledge, new views, or new business innovation opportunities in the face
of various shifts in demographic changes regarding the function of the role of
humans as assets (Human Capital) in sustainable development (Sustainable
Development) for the benefit of companies/organizations. Not only that, but it
can also open up new market opportunities at home and abroad for economic
actors, MSMEs, companies and organizations in Indonesia.
METHOD�� RESEARCH
Literature Review
1. Historical Approach
According to experts, a policy cannot be
separated from the demographic aspect. Demographics is a description of the
structure population, especially regarding births, deaths and migration.
Demographics includes shifts in population size, geographic distribution, and
population composition, among other variables, and how these factors will
change over time. It is said that there are three variables which are very
influential on changes in the number and growth of the population in addition
to other demographic variables that also have an effect. These components can
be measured by birth rates, death rates and migration rates to determine the
extent to which the population can be controlled, the age composition and the
rate of population growth or decline. The question that often arises today is
that you want a large population, but the quality is low; or do we want a small
population, but high quality? or do we want a large population with high
quality? Certainly, no country wants a small population along with low quality.
Population has become a debate among
population and economic experts in the efforts to be carried out to improve the
welfare of the community, all of which aim to reduce poverty and hunger for
residents in various countries in the world. The minutes of pros and cons
concerning population and the economy continue to roll as follows (Oey-Gardiner &
Gardiner, 1997):
1. In 500 years BC (BC), Confius (an ancient
Chinese thinker), has discussed the relationship between the population and the
standard of living of the people. Confius said in his
emphasis on two main things, namely: (1) population growth that is too large
will suppress people's living standards, (2) There is an optimal relationship
between population and land.
2. Two ancient
Greek thinkers who lived in an era (history of 300 BC), namely Plato and
Aristotle, stated that the population will affect the optimal area of a
country. For this reason, birth restrictions are needed (if the population
exceeds the optimal number).
3. The thinkers
of the 18th-19th centuries, who are classified as classical school thinkers,
include Adam Smith, Jean Baptist Say, and David Recardo,
say that population (in this case considered as labor)
is one of the factors of production in the economy, in addition to land,
capital and entrepreneurship. For entrepreneurs, residents will provide added
value to the output of goods and services at least equal to the wages paid for workers.
Thus, it is hoped that the demand for labor will be
born.
4. The theory
of Thomas Robert Malthus (17666-1834), according
to the classification of economics is also included in this classical school in
his book entitled An Essay on the Principle of Population, says that the
population should increase in accordance with the increase in production
resources, especially natural resources. natural. But in reality
the quantity and quality of natural resources that can be used by humans tends
to decrease, and vice versa the population continues to increase. It is said
that it will limit human life, unless population growth is controlled, either
by natural constraints (natural disasters, epidemics) or by human behaviour,
crime, and self-restraint.
5. Another
Malthusian thought was the idea of a geometric increase in population (1, 2, 4,
8...) and an arithmetical increase in food (1, 2, 3, 4...,). Malthus's work
received criticism from various experts, because at that time experts believed
that natural resources would not run out.
6. Karl Marx
(late 19th century), who said that thoughts that put the population as a factor
of production have caused one group of people (the capitalists) to dominate
another group (the proletariat).
7. Neo-Malthusianism
groups again highlight the predictions of Malthus and they argue that it is the
population that causes a lot of poverty. Ansley Coale
and Edgar Hoover in their book "Population Growth and Economic Development
in Low Income Countries" (1958), reveal that poverty in some countries is
not caused by by a lack of demand but by a lack of
production capacity, due to low investment. Low investment is due to the
absence or lack of public savings. There is no savings due to the high level of
public consumption. Consumption is high because the population has many
children. The money earned in a family is used up to support the children's
life, the rest for various physical investments is neglected. This means that
many children are the cause of poverty. Therefore, Coale
and Hoover suggest population control, as a way out to overcome poverty.
8. The above
matters are supported by the results of research by Paul Harrison in the UNFPA
report (1992) which states that the relationship between population and
economic development in developing countries is a war against poverty and
illiteracy will only be greatly helped if the rate of population growth can be
suppressed.
9. This
understanding of Neo- Malthusianism is also evident in the thoughts of Environmentalists,
where this group always associates population growth with environmental issues.
One example of this is the Club of Rome, which published a book entitled The
Limit of Growth in 1972 (Donnela H. Meadows et. all),
saying that if population growth is not inhibited, the world will not be able
to accommodate the number of people who are increasing every year. According to
their calculations, the world's capacity will only be able to accommodate
population growth for another 100 years.
10. Other thinkers
in the environmentalist group mentioned above later joined The World Commission
on Environment and Development. Then in 1987, this commission published a
report entitled Our Common Future, which contained thoughts on a new
development concept. The new development concept is called Sustainable
Development or sustainable development. According to them, that the world's
population continues to increase, development in all countries in the world can
only be sustainable (sustainable) if all existing resources are used wisely. As
previously mentioned, the analysis of capital accumulation in the economy which
continues to attract the attention of experts with their experiences in
developing countries, shows that capital accumulation (physical) alone is not enough
to build the economy. It is also added that cultivating physical capital in a
country that does not have adequate human capital is said to be unlikely to be
successful in the long run.
2. Demographic Aspect
a. In 2021 the
world's population has reached 7.9 billion, it is estimated that in 2057 = 10
billion; year 2037 = 9 Billion; year 2023 = 8 Billion;
year 2021 = 7.9 Billion; year 2011 = 7 billion; 1999 = 6 Billion (United
Nations Population Division Estimates, World Population, 2021). Based on
estimates published by the American Census Bureau, the world's population in
February 2021 will reach 7.7 billion people. Seven of the ten most populous
countries in the world are in Asia. This means that 4 billion people live in
Asia.
It is said
that in line with population projections, this number will continue to grow at
a rate unprecedented in history. It is estimated that one-fifth of all humans
who have lived in the last six thousand years are living at this time. It also
added that the world's population had reached 7.8 billion in July 2021.
The
following is a ranking of countries in the world based on population according
to the United Nations Population Agency, 2021:
1. People's
Republic of China (1,412,000 People)
2. India (1,387,600,000
inhabitants)
3. United States (332,486,698
inhabitants)
4. Indonesia
(278,173,879 people)
5. Pakistan (225,839,946
inhabitants)
6. Brazil
(212,332,794 inhabitants)
7. Nigeria (197,911,988
inhabitants)
8. Bangladesh (171,770,628
inhabitants)
9. Russia
152,610,309 inhabitants)
10. Japan (126.417,244
inhabitants), (United Nations Population Agency, 2021).
b. Implications
of the Demographic Revolution.
The impact
of the results of development policies in Indonesia, shows that there has been
a change in the structure and composition of the population (World Pop. UN, 1999), this fact
is seen for the age under five years (toddlers) and the elderly (elderly) to
only 7.1 million in 2020. On the other hand, the number of elderly people
(>65) is expected to increase from 7.1 million in 1990 to 18.5 million in
2020.
There was a
decline in the fertility rate from 5.6 in the 1971 period to 2.3 in the 2000
period, and it is estimated that this figure will continue to decline. Although
the fertility rate continues to decline, Indonesia's population will still show
an increase in the future. Meanwhile, Indonesia's mortality rate is still relatively
high among ASEAN countries, which was 145.2 per 1000 live births in 1971, then
fell again to 51.1 in 1995.
In 2000 it
fell again to 47 babies per 1000 live births. However, this figure is still
relatively high. In 2020, Indonesia's population is estimated to reach 254
million. This situation will affect the dependency ratio between the
unproductive and the productive population. Young dependency ratio shift to the old dependency ratio. The dependency ratio for
young people will decrease from 59.6 in 1990 to 31.1 in 2020. On the other
hand, the dependency ratio for older people will increase from 6.5 in 1990 to
10.3 in 2020 (Ananta A. Cs, 1995). In
shifting changes in the age structure of the population and decreasing the age
dependency ratio like this, it will provide an opportunity called a demographic
bonus or demographic dividend (Human capital). In terms of economy and
humanity, third world countries tend to have high disparities compared to
developed countries, because in general developing countries have not been able
to cope with high population growth, on the other hand, developed countries
show negative numbers.
The 1999
UNDP report on human development� noted that the percentage of income shared in
developing countries had fallen from 56 percent in 1950, to 12 percent in 1960,
and 15 percent in recent years. In developing countries, the gap in global
income between the richest 20 percent of people (average income of US$ 6,195
per year) and the poorest 20 percent (average income of US $ 768 per year) is 8
times, but in Latin America � the region that ranks among the world's leading
inequalities in the distribution of wealth� the gap is 19 times. In that
region, the richest 20 percent of Latin America's people earn an average income
of 17,380 US dollars per year, while the poorest 20 percent earn only 933 US
dollars per year. When globalization is able to produce scientific and
technological progress at a level that was never imagined before, there are
about 1.3 billion people in the third world who live in poverty, or in other
words, there is 1 poor person among the population. In its latest report, the
World Bank (World Bank / WB) estimates that, when entering the new millennium,
there will be 1.5 billion people living in poverty. When viewed from the
region, poverty will be more pronounced in Southeast Asia and Africa.
In the case
of Latin America, according to the latest CEPAL report, the number of poor
people has reached 204 million, and about 90 million of them live in poverty.
More than 1.125 billion people living in developing countries are unable to
meet their basic needs beyond the age of 40, the opportunity to enjoy basic
education and social services is also low. Facing such living conditions, and
in order to maintain their daily lives, they do not hesitate, like their
obligation, to destroy the environment; the interrelationship between poverty
and environmental destruction is influenced by (a combination of) several
factors. One of the factors is uncontrolled growth, which has a negative impact
on developing countries. On a world scale, between 1975 and 1997, the average
annual rate of population growth was 1.6 percent while, in developing
countries, it was 2 percent. And in the poorest countries 2.5 percent. In the
sub- region of Sub-Saharan Africa, the growth rate is alarming, 2.8 percent.
Although predictions for 2015 predict that the annual world population growth
rate will decline (to 1.2 percent) but in developing countries, it is likely to
continue to increase (1.4 percent).
This
phenomenon will produce another problem: the exodus of people to cities, in
search of a better life or, even just to survive, will of course increase the
level of urbanization. The urban population in developing countries has
increased in number from 26.1 percent in 1975 to 38.4 percent in 1997, and it
is estimated that in 2015 it will be 49.1 percent of the total population. This
will result in an increase in population concentration in cities, crowding each
other, worsening health status, insecurity of food supplies, environmental
destruction and other social ills (UN.1999 p.86).
Uncomfortable
social situations and conditions such as the bombing in Washington
DC, USA (2000), the Bali
bombing (2002) and the bombing at the Australian embassy,
Jakarta, made people worry about the nation and state. Things like this will
have an impact on causing disruption to the implementation of development that
will be carried out by governments in various countries. The increasing
complexity and scale of International Finance has raised the potential impact
of instability on the real economy (Geneva reports on the world economy 9,
CEPR/ICMB 2007, International Financial Stability, www, BI.).
Measures to
accelerate development achievement and poverty alleviation absolutely must be
implemented in developing countries, The Millennium Development Goals (MDG's)
represent a step forward in highlighting the plight of the poor, unfortunately
they are silent on a number of goals and objectives of ICPD, in particular, its
core goal of universal access to reproductive health services by 2015 (ESCAP,
Asia-Pacific, Population Journal, Vol.20 N0. 2, Augusts 2005 UN). The impact of
the global economic crisis has surfaced, efforts to accumulate money capital or
human resources in the economy have again attracted the attention of experts
among moderates in the middle of the 21st century. Even in developed countries,
developing countries show that the accumulation of money capital alone is not
enough to build the economy, because the accumulation of money capital in a
country that does not have adequate people will not succeed in the long term.
This means that a large population is no longer a problem but a very large
economic capital if investment in human resources can be implemented properly (Bloom E. D, Canning D et al, 2003, p. 41, ICPD, Cairo,
1994, UN). 1999, Dumairy, 1996).
There are
several concepts of world development which a number of organizations of the
United Nations (UN) agencies that actively monitor developments and various
progress and problems faced in the context of implementing human development in
various countries in the world. One of them is the concept of human development
(Human Development) which has been developed by UNDP and The International
Union for Nature Conservation (1980). Sustainable Economic and Social
Development for Human Development from the perspective of Asia - Pacific. Sustainable
Economic and Social Development for Human Development from the Asia-Pacific
perspective is commonly called sustainable development or in everyday language
it is called sustainable development. According to the Brudtland
report on "Our Common Future" (World Commission on Environment and
Development, 1987) explains that Sustainable Development is a new concept of
economic, social development for Asia Pacific which in its implementation on
the one hand is able to increase the prosperity of a country at this time by
does not sacrifice the interests of development for future generations. Every
development action directed at increasing the economic growth of a country is
always able to consider the availability of existing natural resources for the
benefit of development for future generations (World Commission Environment and
Development, 1987, Our common future, Refreshing course material, 2002, Dhaka
Bangladesh).
There are 2
(two) phenomena that are the focus of attention in the context of Sustainable
Development for Human Development, namely:
1) Limited
natural resources.
Natural resources are limited while human nature
always tries to achieve its level of satisfaction by carrying out various kinds
of economic actions to meet its needs. This means that in every implementation
of efforts to pursue economic growth by utilizing natural resources, it is
necessary to realize that the availability of natural resources is very
limited, therefore every implementation of economic development that leads to
efforts to fulfil human needs at home and abroad must be able to be calculated
carefully. level of availability of natural resources owned wisely. In other
words, a country that is actively carrying out its development should be able
to pay attention to the availability of existing natural resources. This means
that all parties are expected to be able to understand it and then be able to
make savings.
2) Negative
factors as the impact caused by the development on the community and the
surrounding environment.
For humans,
the environment is everything that is around him, whether in the form of living
objects, inanimate objects, real or abstract objects, along with the atmosphere
and conditions that form the interaction between the elements in nature. The
environment is very broad, the environment knows no boundaries, however the
environment in principle, is the environment (water, air, land, social and
others) that cannot be separated from each other. Because the environment knows
no real boundaries, the environment has a unified ecosystem. For example, water
cannot be separated clearly from air, because in the air there are vapors or water spots. Likewise
there are gases dissolved in water. Air is also in the ground, so if the air
contains sulfur dioxide and when it rains, the
rainwater is likely to be acidic, and surface water will also become acidic and
so on. Climate change and global warming are increasingly worrying human life.
It is said that Sustainable development
(sustainable development) is dependent on one another (Gautier, 2006), so that sustainable
development in its implementation has 4 (four) important issues that must be
understood together, namely:
1. The Asia
Pacific perspective of sustainable development has diversity
(multidimensional), each has different problems, on the other hand, each has
the nature of dependence between the economy, social and environment, and has a
single unit (system).
2. The issue of
environmental damage as an impact caused by economic and human activities.
3. The issue of
equity (equity) in relation to the distribution of the availability of
resources for the continuation of human life from one generation to the next.
4. Ecological,
economic and social factors are challenges for development resilience.
The principle of sustainable development
(Sustainable Development for Human Development) has 3 (three) measures, namely
environmental, economic and social. Protection of natural resources is in environmental
measures. He added that the growth of a country's economic development is
indeed important in sustainable development, but it is not enough to be used as
a measure, the extent to which they are related to one another will be
described as follows:
A. Environment
As explained
above that for humans, the environment is everything that is around it, whether
in the form of living objects, inanimate objects, real or abstract objects,
including human behavior, as well as the atmosphere
formed due to the interaction between behavioral
elements in nature. The environment is very broad,
therefore it is not uncommon for it to be grouped to make it easier to
understand. In principle, the environment (water, air, soil, social
interaction, etc.) cannot be separated, because it has no real boundaries but
is a unified ecosystem in forming a system. Countries/people with poor or low
socioeconomic status have low nutritional status, low knowledge about health,
so that their environmental health is poor and their health status is poor. As
a result, many child deaths occur, so their life expectancy is short. This
situation also supports a high birth rate, so there is a young population; so it is classified as a population with a high risk of
infectious diseases, so that infectious diseases continue to exist, thus the
cycle of infectious diseases is complete (Mika Shimizu, 2009).
B. Economy (New
economic development activities).
The economic
aspect is one of the tools to monitor all efforts to support the achievement of
a country's economic growth.����� Even��� environmental modification with social
interaction with the aim of improving human fate does not always work well if
it does not pay attention to the processes that occur in the dynamics of
ecosystems and the economy and their impact on the environment and surrounding
communities.
C. Social
The social
dimension, namely the interaction between individuals, within and groups, is as
a tool to monitor the situation and condition of the security and comfort of
the community to live in the nation and state as well as in an organizational
forum, namely (the extent to which efforts are made to avoid conflicts between
individuals, institutions, interest groups and political interests). Another
thing that often happens is that the human ability to always try to change or
modify the quality of the environment in general depends on the socio-cultural
level. Situations and conditions like this greatly affect the level of
resilience and human survival in organizations that have an impact on the survival
of the next generation seech 4. Human Capital
in Sustainable Development for the company.
(1).
Understanding Capital Etymologically, capital comes from the word
"Capital", which comes from the Latin word, caput, which means�� "head". Meanwhile,���� the meaning
understood, in the 12th and 13th chapters, is funds, supplies of goods, a sum
of money and interest on borrowed money (Berger,
1999, 20).
In this
paper, "capital" is not translated as capital as is usually done by
many people. The reasons, as stated by Lawang (2004; 3) are first,
capital (English) does mean capital, it may be in the form usually used for
spending on physical capital goods, which allows an investment to work. In this
sense, there seems to be no significant objection regarding capital. Second, in
Indonesian, people often use the term "capital knee", meaning that
there is no money to be used as capital for physical capital expenditures,
except for the person's own energy, it can be in the sense of physical energy,
it can also be in terms of skills or a combination of both. Physical power
cannot be separated from skills, but they are not identical. The two cannot be
separated because these skills can only be realized by using physical energy in
terms of using large calories or small calories. But not all the use of
physical energy is combined with skill power. Walking requires physical
exertion, but walking (especially walking) is not a skill as a form of human
capital. For this reason, the concept of capital is not translated as modal.
Third, is the author's own reason, the concept of capital is related to an
investment. Therefore, capital is associated with a fairly long process, which
cannot be directly used enough like the "knee" that is in front of
the eye and ready to be used.
(2) Definition of Human Capital Human capital is
defined as humans themselves�
Who are
personally loaned to companies with their individual capabilities, commitments,
knowledge,and personal
experiences, both physically and non-physically. Although not solely seen from
the individual but also as a work team that has personal relationships both
inside and outside the company. Human capital or human capital is an ability
that is still hidden (Intangible). A person's visible abilities can be
reflected in the completion of daily work with the latest assessment of what
someone in the organization can do, in other words, the capacity of an
individual to perform various tasks in an organization's work.
According to
Malhotra and Bontis (2004), Human
Capital is a combination of knowledge, skills, innovation and a person's
ability to carry out their duties so that they can create added value. In Human
Capital, it has added value for the company through motivation, commitment,
competence and effectiveness of team work, the added value that can be
contributed by employees is in the form of: 1) Competence development owned by
the company; 2) Transfer of knowledge from employees to the company; 3) Changes
in management culture. Andrew Mayo in Ongkodihardjo (2008:40) defines
Human Capital as a combination of genetic inheritance, education, experience,
and behavior about life and business. Based on the
above opinion, it can be concluded that Human Capital is everything about
humans with all the capabilities they have. So that it can create value for the
organization to achieve its goals.
(3) Human
Capital Theory
Human
capital theory is a thought that assumes that humans are a form of capital or
capital goods as other capital goods, such as land, buildings, machinery and so
on. Human capital can be defined as the total amount of knowledge, skills and
intelligence of the people of a country. The quality of human capital,
according to Romer (1996), consists
of the ability, expertise and knowledge of a person (worker). Thus
conventionally, the quality of human capital is something that must be
separated/appreciated separately. Meanwhile, according to Hildebrand
(1995), what is included in the quality of human capital is
the level of nutrition, life expectancy, expertise, knowledge, abilities and
attitudes (attitudes). Both of these opinions provide a limitation that the
quality of human capital is a separate capital that cannot be equated with mere
physical capital.
The
investment (Human Capital) is carried out with the aim of obtaining a higher
level of consumption in the future, which although there is still controversy
regarding the treatment of human resources as human capital has not been
resolved, the theories of some classical and neoclassical economists, such as
Adam Smith, Von Therenen, and Alfred Marshall agree
that human capital consists of skills acquired through education and useful for
all organizations/companies as well as for society. These skills are the main
force for economic growth. Humans are as capital/assets (Human Capital) in
sustainable development. Humans are subjects and not objects in
development/companies/organizatio ns, meaning that
every time they take an action, any activity in a product or service
company/organization in the implementation of development by the government
focuses on human welfare and interests, and seeks to control the various
damages caused, has an impact on the environmental damage of today's society
and for generations to come.
Sustainable
human resource development (SHD) was introduced in 1990 by The United Nations
Population Fund (UNFPA), Sustainable human development in the sustainable
development program has an emphasis on human resources to have physical and
non- physical resilience quality physique. The development of quality human
resources aims to make efforts to improve the quality and ability of the people
of a nation and state (Sen, 1987). Efforts to
develop human resources are a way of cultivating capital (assets) or also as
potential investments in the sustainable development of a nation and state. In
its dynamics, sustainable human resource development in the implementation of
sustainable development is a model which in the dynamics of the process leads
to various strategies and policies to create quality human resources (People centered), where the human resource in question is expected
to be someone who able to decide things that are beneficial for themselves and
also for the benefit of all parties. It is necessary to realize that designing
a model for sustainable human resource development in sustainable development
is not easy. Various changes will surface, all of which will be able to
increase new sustainable economic growth for generations to come.
By
increasing the quality of human resources through sustainable development
programs (Sustainable Human Development), this will be able to create a
conducive social environment in the state. It is hoped that every resident who
has been able to increase his knowledge and abilities will get direct
employment opportunities, as well as will be able to improve the lives of the
surrounding community. One thing that should be noted from the experience so
far shows that the increase in GNP is difficult to be used as a measure of the
success of a country's development, because the growth of GNP cannot be felt as
a whole by the individual community. The success of achieving economic
development growth alone can no longer promise to be used as a benchmark for
the success of a development in various countries, because the growth of GNP,
GDP is different from the reality of the actual situation and social conditions
of society. Therefore, in 1990 UNDP introduced a standard for measuring the
success of development for every country in the world called the Human
Development Index (HDI), which will be described as follows.
Human
Development Index (Human Development Index-HDI).
The Human
Development Index (HDI) is an indicator, benchmark for development models based
on the humanitarian paradigm or people centered
development with a focus on human development (Human Growth; 2 Welfare (wellbeing),
3 Justice (equity) and 4. Sustainability (sustainability). sustainability
through the human-based development paradigm which was developed by The United
Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNCRD) in 1985 based on the thoughts of
Goulet (1973), Illich (1973) and Ramos
(1976) as a critical response to the failure to implement critical responses.
growth paradigm based on production or GNP (Production centered
development, Rostow, (1961-1970) and welfare
centered development paradigm, Myrdall (1970 -1980).
By observing
the situation and conditions of demographic changes in various countries and
comparing them with the realities felt by the people directly in other
countries, in almost every country there are economic and non-economic
disparities that result in poverty in various countries (World
Population Aging 1950-2050, UN, 2001). 1999; UN, 1995; ICPD Cairo 1994; UNESCAP
Journal Vol.20, 2005).
Since 1990,
the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) has issued an indicator that is
able to measure the extent of human resource development in sustainable
development (Human Development) carried out in various countries in the world.
This indicator is called the Human Development Index, or HDI for short. Human =
Human; Development = Development; Index = Index (a measure commonly used to
compare a different value from certain predetermined variables. Human
Development Index is a picture of index numbers used to assess and compare the
development of changes from a set of variables of development activities
directed at human resource development from time to time in different countries
in the world. Regarding the HDI value, the population of a country is divided
into 3 (three) groups of countries consisting of low, middle and high-income
countries. Concerning the financing of human development programs is an
important matter. There are 4 (four) financial sources for human resource
development, including:
1. Primary
income, which is how much the community gets is primary income. Regarding the income
of the population, it will be possible to obtain the extent to which what they
do is a source of community income.
2. Government
spending; namely how much government revenue is obtained from public income
(primary income) as part of the income derived from direct or indirect taxes.
Government spending is prioritized to finance social programs, direct
assistance to human development.
According to the Human Development Report
1991, there are 4 (four) ratios that are able to analyse the human development
finances carried out by a government:
a. The ratio of
public expenditure, which is what percentage of national income is allocated to
finance the interests of the community.
b. The
percentage of expenditure allocated to finance social services is the ratio of
expenditure to national income.
c. The
percentage of social spending allocated specifically for humanity is called the
social priority ratio.
d. The large
ratio of public expenditures allocated for efforts to improve the quality of
human resources.
From the description above, it can be seen
to what extent the situation and conditions of economic, environmental and
social development are being carried out, not only that but also the extent to
which the government's efforts and capabilities are able to create and
implement patterns of balance between social and environmental economic
development in a sustainable manner. every action taken.art1
below).
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
1. According to
Peter F Drucker in his book Post Capitalist Society (1993)
reveals that
the world has now undergone a dramatic transformation in various aspects of
economic, political, social, organizational and moral landscape life. In the
socio-political sector there was a paradigm shift from the original
nation-state to me-state. A country can no longer dominantly impose its
hegemony on a region but tends to require the cooperation of political economy
blocs. The formation of the European Union, the G20, and most recently the MEA
are real examples of this. In the social sector, for example, there is a shift
in the pattern of community interaction which was originally limited by local
customs, culture and tastes, now with the development of technology from
various smartphone applications, the world community is becoming more homogeneous
and cultural barriers and local tastes are increasingly fading into global
tastes. In the field of economics, Drucker analyses that there has been a
significant shift in the factors of production, initially the factors of
production that played an important role were capital (money), labour and land,
now labour alone is not enough. A workforce with knowledge or commonly called
Human Capital is a production factor that has a vital role.
Economic
growth can no longer rely on production factors in the form of money and land
capital, but there has been a shift where Human Capital is a key production
factor to achieve sustainable economic growth and is a weapon for a country to
win global competition (Competitive Advantage of Nation). decades ago the economy was ruled by the owners of capital be it
kings, political figures or an oligopolist, now a young man in T-shirts who
dropped out of Harvard university could become the most influential economic
figure in the world. This phenomenon is labeled by
Drucker as a knowledge-based economy. If Drucker bases his analysis on the
point of view of a management and organizational expert, this paper wants to
further analyze the knowledge- based economy from the
point of view of economics.
2. Knowledge
Based Economy
Knowledge is
actually not a new thing that is used in the preparation of economic models and
theories, work specialization initiated by Adam Smith basically refers to a
worker who is able to make a contribution to the production process which is
economically useful and productive science. Fredich
List has the approach of infrastructure and institutions as a driving factor
for the formation of a productive labour force through the formation and dissemination
of knowledge. While the most recent Romer and Grossman tried to develop a
theory of economic growth based on knowledge base growth.
According to
the production function initiated by neo-classical economics, the return on
investment will decrease when there is additional capital in the economy, as a
reduction effect due to the use of new technology in the production process.
Although they realize that the use of technology is an engine of growth, they
do not carry out further analysis on it. However, in the last decade,
economists have begun to focus on the focus of their research on this matter.
Based on that research, they found that new technology (in this case) connoted
as knowledge can encourage an increase in return on investment with the argument
that knowledge can stimulate the efficiency of production methods. Also, the
creation of innovative new products from developing.
If the new
technology is proven to be able to increase the return on investment, then the
next investment will return to doing or knowledge. This sustainable investment
in knowledge will ultimately encourage a country's economic growth. A study
conducted by the OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development)
institution shows that on average 50% of the GDP of OEDC strong countries is a
contribution from this knowledge- based economic sector. This is because these
countries are continuously investing in knowledge-based sectors. Therefore, it
is not surprising that a survey conducted in Europe and America by the OECD
found that business investment in knowledge- based sectors contributed 20-34 of
everage lebor productivity
growth.
3. Human
capital and economic problems
According to
Paul Turner (2002) in Human
Resources Forecasting and Planning (Developing practice) said that "This
new era presents challenges for the people, for society as a whole, and for the
organizations in which they work", "People management is becoming
more important in the achievement of organizational success, and we have
evidence to prove it��The New era of labor . This means that in the era of demographic shifts, the
demographic transition provides a new view of the function of the role of human
resources in organizations. Even though economic theory and policies are
designed with the aim of achieving the prosperity of a nation, in practice
economic development still leaves unfinished problems. Unemployment, income
inequality between the richest and poorest, distribution or equity of the
development cake are still tests and challenges for economists. How to create
policy formulas and strategies that combat or reduce these problems. According
to the theory of the vicious cycle of poverty, poverty will result in a person
not being able to access a good education. In terms of the level and quality of
education itself is the key for someone to enter the world of work and the
level of income earned in the future.
While the
level of income will determine whether he is able to access a good education or
not, and so on. So that the poor will tend to continue to be poor. Therefore,
to overcome this problem, mitigation measures are needed in the form of
government policies to provide access to education for the poor for free
because according to the above theory, good education is one way out to cut the
chain of poverty that has been passed down from generation to generation.
4. Human
Capital in Indonesia
By looking
at several relevant aspects describing the quality of human resources in Indonesia,
namely the demographic condition of the Indonesian population, labour
conditions and the quality of the Indonesian human development index with the
level of literacy of the Indonesian people compared to other countries, in
2015, Indonesia was the country that occupied ranks 4th largest population in
the world, with a population of about 253 million people. Based on the
demographic composition of the population, of the 253 million people, 27.3% are
people aged 0-14 years, 67.3% are people aged 15-64 years and 5.4% are aged 65
years and over. This figure indicates that the percentage of the population of
productive age (15 � 65) years is greater than the percentage of the population
of non-productive age (0 � 14) years and 65 +) with a composition of 67.3%
compared to 32.7%. This means that the level of dependence of non-productive
age on productive age is 32.7% / 67.3%. This dependency rate is projected to
continue to shrink and will reach its peak in 2020, where the percentage of the
productive age population is 70% compared to the non-productive age population
of 30%. This kind of demographic condition is called the Demographic Bonus
(Demographic dividend) where the number of productive age population is much
larger than the number of non- productive age population (Source: Indonesian
Population Projection 2010-2035; Bapenas, BPS, United
Nation Population Fund 2013).
The
Demographic Bonus can not only be a blessing but can also be a problem. It all
depends on the following two things. First, is the availability of sufficient
employment opportunities for the productive age population, so that the
population can financially and non- financially support the existence of the
non-productive age population. Second, the working age population (1 to 65
years) will be truly productive when equipped with adequate education and skills.
Because if they don't, they will actually increase the number of unemployed
when they can't compete with other workers from abroad who have good skills and
abilities when ASEAN free trade flows are truly opened. Are the above two
Demographic Bonus prerequisites met? The data presented below will try to
answer these questions (see table 1.):
Employment:
Data from
the survey results from the Central Bureau of Statistics (BPS), show that although
the percentage of the number of unemployed in productive age has been
relatively stable in the last three years, the absolute number has been
increasing. Thus, in real terms, this number will increase the number of
non-productive-population more and more. If the number of non-productive age
population increases, then this means that the percentage of the unemployed
productive age population will increase compared to the non- productive age
population or in other words, the dependency ratio of non- productive age to
productive age will be higher:
Table 2
Open unemployment by
The highest education completed in 2012 � 2015
No |
Educational Level |
2012 |
2013 |
2014 |
2015 |
1. |
Never been
to school |
85,374 |
81,432 |
74,898 |
55,554 |
2. |
No / not finished elementary school |
512,041 |
489,152 |
389,550 |
371,542 |
3. |
Elementary School |
1,452,047 |
1,347,555 |
1,229,652 |
1,004,961 |
4. |
Junior High School |
1,714,776 |
1,689,643 |
1,566,838 |
1,373,919 |
5. |
General Senior high
school |
1,867,009 |
1,925,660 |
1,962,786 |
2,280,029 |
6. |
Vocational High School |
1,067,009 |
1,258,201 |
1,332,521 |
1,569,690 |
7. |
Academy/ Diploma |
200,028 |
185,103 |
193,517 |
251,541 |
8. |
University |
445,836 |
434,185 |
495,143 |
653,586 |
TOTAL |
7,344,866 |
7,410,931 |
7,244,905 |
7,560,822 |
The
performance of the Indonesian economy, which tends to slow down in recent
years, is marked by a declining economic growth, around 5.58% in 2013, to 5.02%
in 2014 and 4.73% in 2015. This phenomenon brought the impact of a wave of
Layoffs in a number of areas in Indonesia throughout 2015. The higher the
unemployment rate, the higher the dependency ratio of the productive age
population. If this condition occurs continuously, the Demographic Bonus will
be a problem for the government.
5. Human
Development Index
In the
previous review, it was stated that the demographic bonus obtained by the
Indonesian state will depend on the quality of human resources and the
government's ability to provide employment opportunities for the growing
population of productive age.
Good quality
human resources will be easily absorbed by the job market. In addition, it can
be a driver of economic growth through product and technological innovation
that results in productivity. High productivity ultimately triggers economic
growth in a country. To measure the quality of a country's human resources,
there are at least two important parameters that can be used as a reference,
namely the first is the Human Development Index or human development and the
literacy index (Table 3).
Trends
in Indonesia's Human Development Index (HDI).
Indicators of HDI |
1990 |
1995 |
2000 |
2005 |
2010 |
2011 |
2013 |
Average World
HDI Value |
0,594 |
0,613 |
0,634 |
0,660 |
0,679 |
0,682 |
0,702 |
Indonesian HDI |
0,481 |
0,527 |
0,543 |
0,572 |
0,613 |
0,617 |
0,684 |
Life expectancy |
62,1 |
64 |
65,7 |
67,1 |
68,9 |
69,4 |
70,8 |
School Year Expectation Rate |
10,3 |
10,5 |
11,1 |
11,8 |
13,2 |
13,2 |
12,7 |
Average Years of School |
3,3 |
4,2 |
4,8 |
5,3 |
5,8 |
5,8 |
7,5 |
GNI Per Capita (2011 DP$) |
4337 |
5.930 |
5308 |
6547 |
8267 |
8642 |
9.446 |
HDI Ranking |
76 |
104 |
109 |
110 |
125 |
124 |
108 |
Total Number
of Countries |
130 |
174 |
174 |
177 |
187 |
187 |
187 |
Sumber: UNDP 2015
In
http://hdrstats.UNDP.org/en/counlnes/profiles/idn.html
The Human Development Index, which is a
parameter that has been developed to measure the success of a country's
economic development with more comprehensive parameters, is not only focused on
economic growth or GDP.
If we look at the facts from the available
data, Indonesia's HDI ranking is still low out of 187 countries in the world
surveyed, Indonesia is in the order of 108. Meanwhile, among other countries in
the ASEAN region, Indonesia is ranked 5th under Singapore, Brunei, Malaysia and
Thailand. However, if examined in more detail, the various HDI indicators
above, especially those related to expected years of schooling and mean years
of schooling, show increasing developments, so that Indonesia's HDI ranking in
2010 � 2013 has increased.� However, the
developments experienced by other ASEAN countries are much better than Indonesia's.
This shows that Human Capital as a capital to compete with other countries in
ASEAN is still very low, let alone competing at the world level.
CONCLUSION
Humans are the heart of the company/organization, they provide
knowledge, skills, and passion that create, maintain and continue the
organization's journey.
Demographic
changes are internal and external forces that directly or indirectly become new
business opportunities for the survival of the company/organization. This means
that only companies/organizations that are observant in using statistics, the Demographic revolution along with
the variables listed therein that can grow oriented towards growth and profit
will be able to dominate the global market today and in the future in a
sustainable development that will be able to survive. in facing the current era
of world transition.
All over the world, communities, companies/organizations are
currently pursuing the ultimate goal of sustainable economic development with a
clean environment.
Demographic
revolution, and the various variables that influence it and its influence on
the shift in the function and role of human resources (Human Capital), in
Sustainable Development (Sustainable Economy, Social Development for Human
Development perspective Asia Pacific) is an attempt to design a new model, a
new era sustainable development that is people centred. Sustainable Development for Human
Development from the Asia Pacific (SHD) perspective is a new view, opens new
insights, new opportunities, new challenges in facing various shifts in
demographic changes regarding the function of the role of humans as assets
(Human Capital) in companies/organizations in the era of sustainable
development (Sustainable Development). So various changes (Changed), presumably
can be used as new business opportunities, open a wider market at home and
abroad for companies/organizations in Indonesia. reed presumably can be done
wisely balanced. Human Capital is the main capital in sustainable development.
Demographic Evolution with various shifts in demographic variables
currently has an impact on demographic transitions in various countries in the
world, each of which has different demographic
characteristics. For example, an epidemiological (health) transition has
occurred, namely the shift in the types of diseases that cause death from
malnutrition to other diseases, for example (Covid-19); Human life expectancy
will increase from 60 years old in the 1970s to 70 in 1990, this shows that
they will increasingly have the potential to enjoy the returns on human capital
investments that have been made during the first 25 years of their lives., and so forth. Demographic evolution has opened and
provided innovation opportunities and new challenges for
companies/organizations in an effort to produce a product or service that is
needed by humans in various countries in the world today. Various changes are
also shifts that occur in various countries in the world, indicating that all
parties involved in it are different from each other.
Sustainable Economic and Social Development for Human Development
from the Asia-Pacific perspective is commonly called sustainable development or
in everyday language it is called sustainable development. According to the
Brudtland report on "Our Common Future" (World Commission on
Environment and Development, 1987) explains that Sustainable Development is a
concept of economic, social development for Asia Pacific which in its
implementation on the one hand is able to increase the prosperity of a country
at this time without sacrificing development interests for future generations.
Every development action directed at increasing the economic growth of a
country is always able to consider the availability of existing natural
resources for the benefit of the development of future generations (World
Commission Environment and Development, 1987, Our common future, Refreshing course material, 2002,
Dhaka Bangladesh).
Humans are capital/assets (Human Capital) in sustainable
development. Humans are as subjects��������� and����� not������ as�������� objects in
development/companies/organizations, meaning that every time they perform an
action, any activity that produces goods or services in a company/organization
in the implementation of development by the government focuses on the welfare
and interests of humans, and seeks to control various the damage caused, has an
impact on the environmental damage of today's society and for generations to
come. Efforts to develop human resources are a way of
cultivating capital (assets) or also as potential investments in the
sustainable (sustainable) development of a nation and state. In its dynamics,
sustainable human resource development in the implementation of sustainable
development is a model which in the dynamics of the process leads to various
strategies and policies to create quality human resources (People centred),
where the human resources in question are expected to be someone who able to
decide things that are beneficial for themselves and also for the benefit of
all parties. It is necessary to realize that designing a model for sustainable
human resource development in sustainable development is not easy. Various
changes will surface, all of which will be able to increase new sustainable
economic growth for generations to come. By increasing the quality of human
resources through sustainable development programs (Sustainable Human Development), this will be able to create a situation and
condition of a conducive social environment in the state. It is hoped that
every resident who has been able to increase his knowledge and abilities will get
direct employment opportunities, as well as will be able to improve the lives
of the surrounding community.
The performance of the Indonesian economy, which tends to slow down
in recent years, is marked by a declining economic growth, around 5.58% in
2013, to 5.02% in 2014 and 4.73% in 2015. This phenomenon brought the impact of
a wave of Layoffs in a number of areas in Indonesia throughout 2015. The higher
the unemployment rate, the higher the dependency ratio of the productive age
population. If this condition occurs
continuously, the Demographic Bonus will be a problem for the government. It is
hoped that the demographic transition with various aspects of demographic
variables that influence it in sustainable development, and human capital in it
as capital/asset in companies/organizations, will be able to open new jobs and
demographic bonuses will encourage increased economic growth in Indonesia today
and in the future. will come continuously. It is also expected to add
knowledge, insight into new views, new opportunities, and new challenges in
facing various shifts in demographic changes regarding the function of the role
of humans as assets (Human Capital) in sustainable development (Sustainable
Development) for the benefit of companies/organizations. Another thing that is
no less important is that the various changes that occur can be used as
opportunities for new business innovation, as well as opening up new markets,
new job opportunities for demographic bonuses for the benefit of economic
actors in companies/organizations in Indonesia.
REFERENCES
Arief, Sritua, 1990, �Dari Prestasi
Pembangunan Sampai Ekonomi Politik,� Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta.
Amdt, Heinz W, 1993, �Pembangunan
Ekonomi Indonesia-Pandangan Seorang Tetangga,� Gajah Mada University Press,
Yogyakarta.
Aris A, 1995,
�Transisi Demografi, Pendidikan, Kesehatan,� LDUI, Jakarta.
Ananta
A, et. all, 1995, �Perkembangan Penduduk Indonesia,� Kantor Menteri
Negara Kependudukan, Jakarta.
Alarcon, J.V.Heems.S. Keuning .W,
1990, �The Sosial Accounting Frame Work for Development,
Concept, Construction and Application,� Evebury, UK.
Cusworth
F.TR, 1993, �Managing Projects in Developing Countries,� Longman
Group, UK.
Biro Pusat
Statistik, 1975,� Penduduk Indonesia Hasil Sensus Penduduk Tahun 1971, Seri D,�
Jakarta.
Bloom
and Canning. D, et al, 2002,� The Demographic Divident,� Rand�s
Pittsburgh, USA
Booth, Anne, 1994,�
Ledakan Harga Minyak dan Dampaknya Kenerja Ekonomi Indonesia dalam era Orde
Baru,� Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta.
Bray M, 1996,�
Counting the Full Cost, Parental the Community Financing of Education in����� East Asia, UNICEF, Washington, DC
Chenesnais, Jean-Claude, 1992,� The Demographic
Transition, Stages, Patterns and Economic Implications,� New York, Oxford
University Press.
Dhal,
Robert A, 1992,� Demokrasi Ekonomi Sebuah Pengantar,� Obor,
Indonesia, Jakarta.
Drucker
Peter. F ( 1993), � Post-Capitalist Society,� Elsevier Science, USA
Dumairy, 1995,� Evaluasi
Kebijakan Pemerintah���� Menanggulangi
Masalah Kemiskinan dan Kesenjangan,� Aditya Media- ICMI-PPSK, Yogyakarta.
Dwiyanto,
Agus, dkk, 1996,� Penduduk dan Pembangunan, Aditya Media dan Pusat
Kependudukan,� UGM, Yogyakarta.
Effendi,
Tadjuddin Noer, 1995,� Mobilitas Pekerja, Remitan dan Peluang
Berusaha di Pedesaan,� Jurnal MM-UGM Yogyakarta.
Gie,
Kwik Kian, 1994,� Analisis Ekonomi Politik Indonesia,� Gramedia Pustaka
Utama dan STIE IBII, Jakarta.
Glassburner,
Bruce,1971,� The Economy of Indonesia Selected Reading,� Cornell
University Press, Itaca, New York.
Glassburner, Bruce & Aditiawan
Chandra, 1981,� Teori dan Kebijaksanaan
Ekonomi Makro,� LP3ES, Jakarta.
Goeltom,
Miranda S, 1994,� Prospektif Bisnis Indonesia Putaran Uruguay,� Jurnal MM-UGM, No.7/11, Yogyakarta.
Goeltom, Miranda S, 1994,� Kinerja
Perdangan������ Internasional Indonesia,�
Jurnal MM-UGM, No. 7/11, Yogyakarta.
Hasibuan,
Nuriman, 1994,� Ancaman Kerapuhan Struktural Industri Pengolahan di
Indonesia,� Jurnal MM-UGM, No.6/11, Yogyakarta.
Harijatimadji,
2003 �,� Kebijakan Kependudukan di Indonesia Analisis Data Sensus
dan Survey, Warta Demografi, LDUI, Jakarta.
Institute of Social Studies and
Planning Commision of Bangladesh, 2002, � Accounting for
Sustainble Economic and Social Development (ASESD), MOD 140, for
Refressher Course�,
Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Institute of Sosial Studies and
Planning Commision of Bangladesh, 2002, MOD 142, SAM
based model and basic prisiples of CGE modeling,� for Refresher Course, Dhaka,
Bangladesh. 2002,� MOD
100, Sustainability
and Human Development, for For Refresher course, Dhaka, Bangladesh.,�� 2002,�
MOD
111, �The New SNA,
Struktural and Main Components for Refresher Course,� Dhaka, Bangladesh., 2002,
MOD
112, �Integrated
Environmental and Economic Accounting Frame Works,� for Refresher Course,�
Dhaka, Bangladesh., 2002, MOD
113, �The SAM as
Data Framework for Social Economic Analysis,� for Refresher Cource,� Dhaka,
Bangladesh.,2002, MOD
114,� The SAM as a
Data Framework for Social Economic Analysis Exercise,� For Accounting for
Sustainable Economic and Social Development ( ASESD) of Refresher Course,
Dhaka, Bangladesh., 2002, MOD
150,� The SAM Based
General Equilibrium Model for Development Policies II, Case Study-SHD
System- Bangladesh,� For Refresher Course, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Karseno, Arief
Ramelan, 1994,� Perdagangan Indonesia dengan Negara-negara ASEAN dan APEC,�
Jurnal MM-UGM, No.
11/4, Yogyakarta.
Kelley,
Allen. C, 1993,� Revisionism Revisited,� An Essay on the Population
Debate in Historical Perspective on Population, Development and Walfare,� The
Nobel Jubille Symposium in Economics, Berlin.
Keynes,
John Maynard, 1991,� Teori Umum Mengenai Kesempatan Kerja, Bunga dan
Uang, Edisi Bhs. Indonesia, Penerjemah Willem H. Makaliwe, Yoyakarta, Gajah
Mada University Press, Yogyakarta.
Kotler
P, 1997,� Manajemen Pemasaran,� Alih Bahasa Hendra Teguh,
Prehallindo, Jakarta.
�Munasinghe.M
et al, 2001,� The Sustainability of Long-Term Growth,
Socioeconomic and Ecological Perspective ed,� USA.
Mayo
A, 2000, � The Role of Employee Development in The Growth of
Intelectual Capital,� Personal Review, Vol 29, No 4. http://www, emerald �
library.com
Purwaningsih,
2003, Faktor-faktor yang mempengaruhi Penanaman modal, STIS,
Jakarta.
Samosir,
J. T. 2006, �Sustainable Economic and Social Development Pada
Perusahaan�, UBK Press, Jakarta.
Sihombing.
S, 2004,� Sepintas tentang Laporan Pembangunan Manusia Indonesia,�
Jurnal Berdaya, Vol.II No. 12, Jakarta.
Slamet.
J.S, 1994,� Kesehatan Lingkungan,� Gajah Mada University Press,
Yogyakarta.
Slamet
S. J, 2000,� Kesehatan Lingkungan, �Gajah Mada University Press.
Sukirno S. 1994,�
Pengatar Teori Ekonomi,� Raja Grafindo Persada, Jakarta.
Turner
P, 2002, � HR Forcasting and Planning ,� Developing Practice, Great
Britain, UK.
Tri
Chayono. B, 1996,� Manajemen Strategi,� IPWI, Jakarta.
Todaro. M P, 2000,�
Pembangunan Ekonomi Dunia Ke Tiga, Terjemahan Erlangga.
Ujang
S, 2001,� Pemulihan Ekonomi dan Perlindungan Konsumen, Peran
Kebijakan Moneter dalam Pemulihan Ekonomi
Indonesia,� Agrimedia Vol.6 Nomor 3, Jakarta.
United Nation,
1993-1999,� World Development Report, The World Bank & Oxford.
UN, 1995, �World
Population at The Trun of the Century, Population Studies�, No. 11, New York.
UN. 1995,�
Ineternational Conference on Population���������� and����� Development�, ICPD�Cairo�94, New York.
UN.2001, �Inquiry
Among Governments on Population and Development�, New York, 2001.
UN, 2000, World
Population Monitoring, Population���������� Growth,���������� Structure Distribution�, NY.
UNDP, 1997,� Human
Development Report,� New York, Oxford university Press.
www.bapenas.go.id
www.poptahun.awarness.net
Windiarto, 2009,
�ABFI Perbanas,� No. 2 tahun i- April Juli 2009.
Wie, Thee Kian,
1983,� Pembangunan Ekonomi dan Pemerataan, LP3ES, Jakarta.
Wie,� Thee������ Kian,�� 1994,�� Industrial������� di Indonesia,� LP3ES, Jakarta.
Wie, Tee Kian,
1994,� Rencana PembangunanLima Tahun Keenam 1945/95-1998/1999, RI,� LP3ES,
Jakarta.
Waluyo, H, 2002,
Tekanan Penduduk dan Dampak Terhadap Lingkungan, Round Table Discussion,�
Jakarta.
Copyright holders:
Nahason Sitohang
(2022)
First publication right:
Devotion - Journal of Research and Community Service
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International