TEACHERS� ADAPTATION IN THE USE OF
INSTRUCTIONAL MEDIA IN TEACHING ENGLISH AS A FOREIGN LANGUAGE AT JUNIOR HIGH
SCHOOL IN SUNGAI PENUH
Tiara
Indah Sari, Surono, Estrella Arroyo
Universitas Ahmad Dahlan, Yogyakarta, Indonesia
Email: [email protected],
[email protected], [email protected]
KEYWORDS Instructional Media, English Teaching, Audio-visual,
Hardware, Software |
ABSTRACT In
Indonesia, the number of English learners keep growing. Different methoods and effectiveness in teaching English has been
experimented to get a better achievement. But still the systems, methods and
techniques have some lacks and still need to have improvement and innovation
to solve the problems. The problems are different in every schools,
one of the problems currently faced by teachers was the new adaptation to the
situation where schools activity turned to online activity. Teachers have to
adapt into the new situation where all activities need to be handled through
online activity and it becomes the problems for most of teachers who had no
preparation and facilities during that time. Thus, the way English teachers
adapt intstructional media and how teachers utilize
and apply the instructional media especially audio visual
media will be the main focus of this research. The researcher used suervey as a research design. There will be five junior
high schools included in this study. There are 10 English teachers from
different junior high schools in Sungai Penuh. The
researcher only chose the junior high schools which are A-accredited. The
researcher used questionnaire and interview as the instruments of this
particular study. The researcher employed quantitative and qualitative data.
The quantitative data were taken from close-ended questionnaire while the
qualitative data were taken from interview result. The data analysis results
shows that the teachers at Junior High Schools in Sungai Penuh
used variatif instructional media in teaching. The
researcher found types of audio visual instructional media mostly used among
the teachers to improve student�s skills are audio recording (9,4) (hints,stories,conversation) and
Videos (8,4) (documentaries,tutorials,teaching)
which is very good response. The most used to improve speaking is Song (6,1)
and Picture (7,3) teachers have good response towards them. Next, for reading
is picture (8,8) and last to improve writing skills song (6,4), picture
(6,8), flashcards (5,9), charts (5,7), videos (5,1) also have good response.
Audio drama, movies, TV programs, news broadcast are the media that have bad
response. Additionally, The most used hardware among
the teachers are whiteboard (9,7) printed paper (9,1), smartphone (8,4),
computer /laptop (7,7). Radio, recorder, CD player are get
low response from the teachers. In adapting instructional media, teachers
adapting from concrete object surround the classroom and schools, teachers
also utilze digital devices like smartphone and
software application like Whatsapp and Youtube. Moreover, teachers adapting the existing media
and combined with other media that created by their own to assit them in delivering the materials. In addition,
Teachers at five different junior high schools in Sungai Penuh
have good views towards instructional media. |
INTRODUCTION
English
learning serve special status in Indonesia for instance as an ability of global
communication in practically all fields, as a medium for sciencetific
knowledge, and new technologies can be accesed globally, also as a vocabulary
resource for expansion and modernization of Indonesian and most crucial is as a
way to get to know other�s culture, literature and their language especially in
native speaker country as a means of expanding intellectual for the future (Dardjowidjojo,
2003: 32, Huda, 2000: 65-66, Renandya, 2000: 116, Simatupang, 1999: 64).
In
Indonesia, the number of English learners keep growing. Different methoods and
effectiveness in teaching English has been experimented to get a better
achievement. But still the systems, methods and techniques have some lacks and
still need to have improvement and innovation to solve the problems. The
problems are different in every schools, one of the problems currently faced by
teachers was the new adaptation to the situation where schools activity turned
to online activity. Schools turned to online activity since the affected cases
of Sars-Covid19 in Indonesia got high on march 2019 until the end of 2021.
Moreover, schools in rural area which number of cases low were starting the
offline schools in the middle of 2021. Teachers have to adapt into the new
situation where all activities need to be handled through online activity and
it becomes the problems for most of teachers who had no preparation and
facilities during that time.�
Teachers
need to be creative and innovative by facilitating students with various media
where they can found more enjoyable or even entertaining learning activity out
of the school. So it�s teacher responsibility to create meaningful activity for
students. A junior high school English teacher execute a very urgent
responsibility in qualifying a good input because English is firstly taught in
junior high school. Thus, the way English teachers adapt intstructional media
and how teachers utilize and apply the instructional media especially audio
visual media will be the main focus of this research.
The
main focus of this research is
● What type of media do teachers use in teaching ?
● How do teachers adapting to instructional media ?
● How do teachers utilize of instructional media in teaching and
learning activity ?
● How teacher�s view in using instrucional media ?
A
teacher expected to be able to develop the standard and basic of competence
into the teaching material and indicator of good achievement, so that the
students will be attracted to English, and eventually he/ she will be able to
get a good achievement in learning English as well. Unfortunately, it is not an
easy work for teacher to develop attractive learning that catch students
attention during teaching and learning process and eventually brings the good
results as well. Creating a good innovation and being creative in teaching has
to be done by those who work in education field. In language teaching and
learning, instructional media are used as the aids to explain language meaning
and construction, engage students in a certain topic, or as the basis of the
whole activity (Harmer, 2001).
Literature Review
A. English as a Foreign Language in Indonesia
1.
Teacher�s role in English Language Teaching
Changes are continually made in education. The government for
instance, in this case, the Ministry of Education still try to find a better
solution for education improvement by proposing some curriculum development
than can be implemented in teaching and learning activities, including
English.� For a long time, a teacher is
probably considered as the one and only person in the classroom who knows
everything. He/she is viewed as the content expert and source for all (McGhie-Richmond,
2013). The teacher is the one who controls every single activity in
the classroom, asks a question and gives direction to the student along the
lesson.� But yet, it is all shifted to
students-centered learning approach where the teacher and students�
�responsibilities� are viewed differently. If students passively wait for all
information and direction given by the teacher before, now they have to
actively participate in digging out information related to what will they learn
in the classroom. The teacher has to know how to put him/herself in a proper
position that rather be the one who gives direction and keeps the students on
track than the one who acts as a knowledge supplier for the students. However,
a teacher should be better known as instructional expert as what is proposed by
Woolfolk 1990 than a knowledge source. An instructional expert is the one who
has responsibilities in planning, implementing and evaluating the running
instruction.
B. Adaptation in Teaching
Adaptations are teaching and assessment strategies especially designed
to accommodate a student�s needs so he or she can achieve the learning outcomes
of the subject or course and to demonstrate mastery of concepts (McGhie
& Sung 2013). Essentially, adaptations are �best practice� in
teaching. A student working on learning outcomes of any grade or course level
may be supported through use of adaptations. Adaptations do not represent
unfair advantages to students. In fact, the opposite could be true. If
appropriate adaptations are not used, students could be unfairly penalized for
having learning differences, creating serious negative impacts to their
achievement and self‐concept.
a)
Determine the Type of Adaptation.
During the material preparation, teachers have evaluated the selected
materials and once the possible problem areas are recognized, the type of
format adaptation must be considered. Generally, format adaptations can be made
by:
1)
Altering existing materials
Rewrite, reorganize, add to, or recast, the information, e.g., leave
out things deemed inappropriate, irrelevant, and unproductive; simplify the
language (words and sentence structures); reorder and combine activities. This
helps to make the classroom teaching smoother and more cohesive. It also helps
the teacher to better fulfill the aims of a unit and the students can access
the regular curriculum material independently, e.g., prepare a study guide and
audiotape,
2)
Mediating existing materials
Provide additional instructional support, guidance, and direction to
the students in the use of the materials. Alter the instruction to mediate the
barriers presented by the materials so that the students can be directly led to
interact with the materials in different ways. For example, have students
survey the reading material, collaboratively preview the text, and create an
outline of the material to use as a study guide.
3)
Selecting alternate materials and media
Select new materials that are more relevant to the needs of students
with disabilities or are inherently designed to compensate for learning
problems. For example, use an interactive computer program that cues critical
ideas, reads text, inserts graphic organizers, defines and illustrates words,
presents and reinforces learning in smaller increments, and provides more
opportunities for practice and cumulative review.
C. Instructional Media�
Using appropriate instructional media is one of the key principles in
creating effective instruction (Aini 2013).� Instructional media itself is defined by
Scanlan as all materials that can be used by the teachers to conduct teaching
learning activities and support students in reaching instructional objectives.
Instructional media whether they are operated digitally or
traditionally can be categorized into three forms namely: audio, visual and
audio-visual. Each of them has its own role in stimulating the sensory channels
in order to process the message delivered by the teachers during English
language teaching. Instructional media whether they are operated digitally or
traditionally can be categorized into three forms namely: audio, visual and
audio-visual.
a.
Audio
Audio media undoubtedly deal with the listening experience. Audio is
used in order to stimulate the students� sense of hearing. However, it does not
mean that in English language teaching, audio media are merely used in
listening comprehension activities. Information that is given by the teacher
through audio media to the students supposed to be useful whether in listening
itself, as well as speaking, reading and writing.�
Different audio media are made or probably be utilized by English
teacher whether in listening, speaking, reading or writing activities. The
material can be in the form of audio media such as instruction, narration,
dialog, drama, interview, news report or even a song.
1.
Audio recordings
Audio recordings are reliable in practicing pronunciation, as the
speaker definitely has a good speaking ability, by listening, the students can
improve their speaking ability by repeating the words, phrases or sentences
that they just listened.� The students
are also introduced to some new words from the recording which the meaning can
be figured out as well as learn how to use the words in a sentence.
2.
�Drama
Drama generally consists of narration and dialog. What makes it
different from the dialog and narration in audiotapes is that a drama has a
more complex plot, mostly has more than two characters and it has longer lines
than the audio recordings� dialog. As it is an audio drama, there is no
visualization available, it might get the listener bored, but on the other
hand, it is able to train the students� imagination in visualizing the
characters, plots, and the setting.
3.
News report
Another audio aid that can be functioned as instructional media is
news report. Indeed, news report gives worldwide information that becomes new
knowledge for the students, but there are many other advantages that can be
gained by the use of news report in the classroom. By listening to the news
report, the students obviously can enrich the vocabulary as well as improve
their speaking ability.
4.
Song
Songs are mostly used to enrich the students� vocabularies. Listening
to a certain song and fill in the blank words of the lyric, for instance, can
be one of the ways to introduce new vocabularies to the students.
b.
Visual
Visual media are definitely dealing with the sense of sight. They can
be generally divided into two categories, whether they contain verbal or
nonverbal messages (Munadi, 2010). Verbal messages can be seen in meaningful
words that form certain writing. This might be the most common visual media
that exist in English language teaching. They exist in the form of books,
magazine, newspaper, etc. Whereas nonverbal messages can be seen in pictures,
drawings, charts, graphs, posters and cartoons (Ajayi� & Adeniji 2015). They can be presented in
the form of printed visuals, presentation software, digital images, and
overhead projection.��
Like other media, visual media are also utilizing to assist the
teacher in delivering information in the classroom. Along with delivering
contained-knowledge information to the students, visual media that used by
English teacher are also able to make concrete of abstract ideas, encourage
students, and direct attention. (Smaldino et. al 1996) Visual media,
particularly that contain nonverbal messages ones, can be objectively used to
make English language teaching and learning become more colourful.�
c.
Audio-visual
These particular media are the integration of motion pictures and
sound at a time. Smalindo et. al. (1996) claim that these particular media are
available for almost all educational topic and able to embrace all of the
learning aspects such as cognitive, affective, psychomotor and interpersonal
abilities. They are available in the form of videos (documentary, tutorial, and
lectures), films (drama, fairy tale, biography) and TV programs (news, series,
talk show).� Our recent generation is the
generation that cannot stay away from television, computer and the internet.
Audio-visual media are expected can be the media that are able to deliver a
message (from the teacher) which will be received and processed well by the
students.
1)
Video
There are generally three types of video that used in education namely
documentary, tutorial and lecture. Its ability to bring various benefits makes
video very familiar in English language teaching for such a long time.
Corporation for Public Broadcasting 2004, elaborates some benefits that video
offers such as reinforce reading and learning material and also develop the
students� basic knowledge.� Besides,
video is able to augment the students� understanding as well as their ability
in discussing ideas to one another. Moreover, video is also proved can
facilitate most of the students� learning styles as well as encourage them to
be more motivated and enthusiastic.�
2)
Films
Film is one of the artworks that most of the people have interested
in. It exists in various genre and theme which facilitate various desires of
the audiences. Film, in this context drama, fairy tale, biography can assist
English teacher to run the class. A number of studies have proved that film
brings significant effect to the development of basic language skills which are
listening, speaking, reading and writing (Kabooha, 2016).
3)
Tv Programs
TV program is believed provides some
opportunities in gaining more knowledge of English. It actually has been used
in education field since 1930�s and take part in English language teaching for
about 50 years (Hambrook, 1979) By utilizing TV program in the
classroom, the students do two activities at once which are seeing and
listening, which means they stimulate more than one sense at the same time.
Instructional
media are those media which can deliver a message from the teacher to the
students. They play a role as helpful means in stimulating the students to
learn (Gagne, 1987). Having media in the English language teaching
is believed can bring some benefits for both the teacher and the students. Sanaky
(2013) says that media enrich teacher resources and aids. A teacher
becomes more creative in delivering teaching material to the children since it
is given in many different ways. Media also enable the teacher to use creative
and innovative ways in helping the students to reach learning objectives.
Whereas for the students, media are helpful in creating a livelier and fun
class since the activity does not only focus on the teacher�s preach or
explanation.�� The students are also
stimulated to think analytically since they get the knowledge not directly from
the teacher. Media have a big chance in facilitating the students� different
learning styles since they appear in many different forms.
METHOD
RESEARCH
As
the objective of this study is to investigate teachers� adaptation in the use
of Instructional media, the researcher needs a method that is able to make the
result of this study represents the population of English teachers of junior
high school in sungai penuh. So, in order to gathered the data the researcher
used suervey as a research design. Survey research involves collecting data to
test hypotheses or to answer questions about people�s opinions on some topic or
issue (Lodico et. al. 2006). A survey is an instrument to collect
data that describe one or more characteristics of a specific population. There
will be five junior high schools included in this study. As a respondent in
this study, the number of the teachers is different from one school to another.
There are two respondents from Mtsn 1 Sungai Penuh, SMPn 1 Sungai Penuh, SMPn 2
Sungai Penuh, SMPn 3 Sungai Penuh, and last SMPn 11 Sungai Penuh. Thus, as the
total, there are 10 English teachers from different junior high schools in
Sungai Penuh. The researcher only chose the junior high schools which are
A-accredited.
The
researcher used questionnaire and interview as the instruments of this
particular study. The researcher employed quantitative and qualitative data.
The quantitative data were taken from close-ended questionnaire while the
qualitative data were taken from interview result. The researcher especially
used the close-ended questionnaire as the main instrument in gathering data of
this study. In this section, the researcher used the Likert scale, a scale with
a number of points that provide ordinal scale measurement (Bishop et al, 2015).
The interview list contains some questions about the use of instructional media
anything related to teacher�s activity in the class using instructional media.
It covers in�� what condition does the
teacher decide to use media, what kind of criteria do the media should have so
they can be utilized by the teacher, whether the teacher finds some
difficulties in utilizing the media or not and what is the teacher suggestion
to make the use of Instructional media is more effective.
Data
gathered from the entire provided instruments processed and analyzed to answer
the research question. The result of data analysis guided the researcher in
drawing a conclusion of this study, which is about teachers� adaptation of
media in English language study. Thus, the researcher especially uses Riduwan�s
(2009) formula as the guideline in analyzing the gained data which can be seen
as follow:
a)
Maximum Index Score: Highest Score
x Total of Statements x Total of Samples
b)
Minimum Index Score: Lowest Score
x Total of Statement x Total of Samples Interval range: (Maximum Score �
Minimum Score) : 4
c)
Final Score: (Total of Score:
Maximum Score) x 100
Technically,
the researcher will analyze four different data which are the data of teachers�
adaptation in the use of instructional media, teacher�s type of instructional
media, teachers �action toward software media as well as the hardware, and the
last one is teacher�s view about instructional media. Thus, the researcher
plans to process those four data separately.
Research Finding And Discussion
To
answer the research problems, researcher devided into four sections they are;
type of instructional media used by teachers, the way teachers utilized the
instructional media, the way teachers adapting instructional media and last
teacher�s view on instructional media.
a.
Type of Intructional media used by teachers
NO. |
STATEMENT |
TOTAL SCORE |
CLASSIFICATION |
1 |
I
use AV instructional media below in activities that are aims to improve
students' listening skills: -
Audio recording (hints, stories, conversations) |
9,4 |
Very
good/positive |
|
- Audio drama |
3 |
Bad/positive |
|
-
News broadcast |
2,5 |
Very
bad/negative |
|
- Song |
6,4 |
Good/positive |
|
-
Videos (documentaries, tutorials, teaching) |
8,4 |
Very
good/positive |
|
- Movies (audio
drama, fairy tales, biographies) |
4,8 |
Bad/negative |
|
-
Television programs |
1,4 |
Very
bad/negative |
2 |
I use AV
instructional media below in activities that are aims to improve students'
speaking skills: - Audio recording
(hints, stories, conversations) |
4,5 |
Bad/negative |
|
-
Audio drama |
2,1 |
Very
bad/ negative |
|
- News broadcast |
0,7 |
Very bad/negative |
|
-
Song |
6,1 |
Good/positive |
|
- Picture |
7,3 |
Good/positive |
|
-
Flashcards |
4,2 |
Bad/negative |
|
- Charts |
4,6 |
Bad/negative |
|
-
Videos (documentaries, tutorials, teaching) |
4,9 |
Bad/negative |
|
- Movies (audio
drama, fairy tales, biographies) |
3,8 |
Bad/negative |
|
-
Television programs |
0,8 |
Very
bad/negative |
3 |
I use AV
instructional media below in activities that are aims to improve students'
reading ability: |
|
|
|
-
Audio drama |
1,5 |
Very
bad/ negative |
|
- News broadcast |
1,6 |
Very bad/ negative |
|
-
Song |
5,3 |
Good/positive |
|
- Picture |
8,8 |
Very good/positive |
|
-
Flashcards |
7 |
Good/positive |
|
- Charts |
5,9 |
Good/positive |
|
-
Movies (audio drama, fairy tales, biographies) |
4,7 |
Bad/negative |
4 |
I use AV
instructional media below in activities that are aims to improve students'
writing skills: - Audio recording
(hints, stories, conversations) |
4,4 |
Bad/negative |
|
-
Audio drama |
1,9 |
Very
bad/negative |
|
- News broadcast |
2,2 |
Very bad/negative |
|
-
Song |
6,4 |
Good/positive |
|
- Picture |
6,8 |
Good/positive |
|
-
Flashcards |
5,9 |
Good/positive |
|
- Charts |
5,7 |
Good/positive |
|
-
Videos (text of documentaries, tutorials, teaching) |
5,1 |
Good/positive |
|
- Television
programs |
0,4 |
Very bad/negative |
*Notes
0
≤ x ≤ 2,5 : very bad response, categorized as negative
2,6
≤ x ≤ 5,0 : bad response, categorized as negative�
5,1
≤ x ≤ 7,5 : good response, categorized as positive�
�7,6 ≤ x ≤ 10 : very good response,
categorized as
a)
Software
1.
Listening
Result shows that the teachers� actions are quite different from one
to the other media. There are some media that used frequently in enhancing the
students listening comprehension, but there are also some media that are not
frequently used. Audio recording-whether in the form of instruction, narration,
monolog or dialog- is one of the most frequently used in enhancing the students
listening skills. The score of this particular software is 9,4. It is followed
by videos (documentary, tutorial and lecture) which score�s is 8,4. Both the
software are classified as media with a very good response, which mean most of
the teachers have a very good action toward audio recording and videos. On the
other hand, there are some media that seemed not to be frequently used in
improving the students� listening skill such as�
audio drama, news reportand television program. The score for audio
audio drama software is 3, news broadcast is 2,5 and Television program is 1,4.
That means most of the teachers have a bad response toward those software of
media.�
2.
Speaking
There are only two out of ten software which have a good response from
the teacher, they are picture and song. The highest in this category is picture
by handling 7,3 and for song 6,1. while the rest of them have bad and very bad
response.
3.
Reading
The table shows that there are only four media which is seemed to be
frequently used by the teachers in improving the students� reading skill.
Unfortunately, the other four media are that prior for most of the teachers to
be used in English class when it deals with reading skill.�� The result reveals that picture is the
teachers� favourite assistant to enhance the students� reading skills. It can
be seen from its score which is 88 and it means most of the teachers have a
good action toward that particular medium
4.
Writing
The data collection result reveals that nine media proposed by the
researcher are used by the teachers in a quite different frequency.� Similar to reading skill, most of the
teachers also have a positive action toward picture in enhancing the students�
writing skills.
a)
Hardware
As each of the media presented in the previous section needs hardware
to be delivered in the classroom, this particular section will especially
present teachers� action toward hardware media.
Table
2
Hardware
of instructional media
NO |
SOFTWARE MEDIA |
HARDWARE MEDIA |
SCORE |
CLASSIFICATIONS |
20 |
Audio |
Radio |
1,6 |
Very bad/ negative |
|
|
Recorder/Player,
cassette, CD player |
2,3 |
Very
bad/negative |
|
|
Smartphone |
8,4 |
Very good/ positive |
|
|
Computer,
Laptop |
7,7 |
Very
good/positive |
21 |
Visual |
Paper, Printing Paper |
9,1 |
Very good/positive |
|
|
Whiteboard |
9,7 |
Very
good/positive |
|
|
Computer |
5,5 |
Good/positive |
|
|
Smart
Board |
1,7 |
Very
bad/negative |
22 |
Audio visual |
Television |
1,5 |
Very bad/negative |
|
|
VCD
player, DVD player |
1,5 |
Very
bad/negative |
|
|
Computer, Laptop |
7,7 |
Very good/positive |
|
|
Smartphone |
5,3 |
Good/positive |
*Notes
0
≤ x ≤ 2,5 : very bad response, categorized as negative
2,6
≤ x ≤ 5,0 : bad response, categorized as negative�
5,1
≤ x ≤ 7,5 : good response, categorized as positive�
�7,6 ≤ x ≤ 10 : very good response,
categorized as
1.
Audio
The result shows that most of the teachers have a very good action
toward smartphone and computer in delivering audio software audio visual media.
The score of this particular media are 8,8 for smartphone and 7,7 for
computer/laptop, which is the highest score for this hardware group.
2.
Visual
The result shows that the teachers have different action toward the
hardware. The most highest score is whiteboard; 9,7 and followed by
Paper,printing paper; 9,1. It means that teachers are frequently using
tradtional hardware to assist them in teaching English.�
3.
Audio Visual
In this category, there is only one audio visual hardware that got
very good response, it is computer/laptop by handling 7,7 score. and followed
by smartphone; 5,3. the computer is the prior hardware which is used to deliver
audio-visual media in the classroom.
b)
The way teacher�s adapting and utilize
instructional media
To get information about whether teachers at junior high school in
Sungai Penuh adapting instructional media or not, researcher conduct
close-ended interview and deep-interview for it. The questions that have been
asked are related on the way teacher�s adapt instructional media like what have
presented below.
Table
3
Teacher�s
adapting instructional media
No |
QUESTIONS |
YES |
NO |
1 |
Are
you adapting AV instructional media in teaching? |
7 |
3 |
2 |
Are you using AV
instructiomal media in teaching English for every topic? |
5 |
5 |
3 |
Are
you using AV instructional media in teaching English generally ? |
5 |
5 |
4 |
Do you usually
encounter difficulties in preparing instructional media? |
3 |
7 |
5 |
Is
improving the learning process in using audio visuals your priority goal? |
5 |
5 |
6 |
Is enriching the
linguistic aspect becomes your priority goal in using audio-visual media in
teaching? |
7 |
3 |
7 |
Is
improving language skills becomes your priority goal in using audio-visual
media in teaching? |
8 |
2 |
8 |
Do existing media
provide more information than your created audio visual instructional media ? |
7 |
3 |
9 |
Do
you think a combinationa of both created and existing are the better |
10 |
0 |
10 |
Is AV instructional
media helping students to get better achivement in learning English ? |
10 |
0 |
�����������
`����� Educators are increasingly expected to be
responsible not only for helping students to achieve the best possible
outcomes, but also for using the most scientifically valid methods to achieve
them. One of them is adapting instructional media in teaching.� The first question of the interview was
asking about whether the teacher adapting audio visual instructional media or
not and surprisingly the results shown that most of the teachers said yes and
only three teachers said no. It means that most of the teachers utilize the
audio visual instructional media in teaching English by adjusting with the
needs of the students and the situation and condition of the schools.
Meanwhile, for the three teachers who chose no which means they are not
adapting the audio visual instructional media in teaching. It is acceptable
because there are still teachers who is still lack in digital devices and they
have limited access to it, also the school does not provide the facility of the
media. like what Thamrin, et al (2017) found in his study
about� problems faced by the teacher in
maximizing the use of learning media in padang. From his study he conclude that
there are still teachers who do not have the ability to use media. They are not
able to determine which media can be used to support their teaching.
Not only adapting, teachers or educators must be able to operate the
instructional media. as in the second question, it was about teacher�s
utilization of audio visual instructional media in teaching in every topic of
the English lesson. The result shown that there are five teachers used it for
every topic and the rest are not. It is acceptable that some of the teachers
are not referring to instructional media for every topic one of the reason is
teachers have limited time in the class, during the Sars-Cov19 pandemic the
timing are short and with that short time tecahers are expected to deliver the
material and it takes more time for the teachers if they use devices that needs
to be set up first. The third question is about using audio visual
instructional generally by teachers. same as previous questions five teachers
said yes and the rests are no. Using media in a whole lesson probably hard for
the teachers in this situation, where schools are not fully normal because of
pandemic. Meanwhile, teachers are expected to follow curriculum that has been
designed by gornment, it means they have to make sure that every materials
delivered on the right time as what have scheduled in curriculum. And here what teacher�s said about are they
using audio visual instrcutional media generally ?
Same as at school, we just use
the media that is available in school. We don�t really have much time to use
hardware media because during the pandemic we only got 40-50 minutes\meeting.
If we use hardware media like projector and laptop to show them like video or
picture it will take much time. So every classes I just focused on teaching the
lesson (R2)
The previous problem is time. Most of the schools using projector if
they want to show their students like learning video, clips, slides and et
cetra. And to use the projector, teacher needs to make sure that is the power
is on in the class, where to plug, make sure the background is clean and need
to connect to the laptop. To do all that process with only 40-50 minutes and
delivering the materials are not enough. So other teachers have another
solution for it.�
Fourth question is asking the teachers if they have difficulties in
preparing instructional media. The results show that there are three teachers
said yes and seven teachers said no. It means that only three of them have difficulties
in preparing instructional media. Next question is about using audio visuals
instructional media to improve learning process as their priority goals. This
question is formulated to know if audio visual instructional media can make
teachers move from old teaching styles to digital technology era. The impact of
the digital revolution with its fast-developing information and communication
technologies, liberating learning from constraints of time and space, has been
the single most force in changing traditional forms of teaching (Harman,
2010).
Using audio-visual instructional media attracted students to learn
because it is interesting and also effective for students (Mathew & Alidmat , 2013),
the next question of interview formulated to see if enriching liguistics aspect
becomes teaher�s priority in using audio-visual media in teaching English. The
result show that most of the teachers said yes and only three of them said no.
It means that teacher believes that by giving them a fun activity using audio
and visual instructional media help students to enrich student�s linguistics
aspects which is one of the purposes in tecahing English. For junior high
schools, linguistics aspects include pronounciation, vocabulary, meaning of the
words and etc.
Besides enriching the linguistics aspects, teacher also need to focus
on language skills of the students like speaking, reading, writing and
listening. These are the basic skills that students in junior high school begin
to learn. For this question of the interview about using audio visual media to
improve students language skills as priority goals in teaching and the results
are showing that most of the teachers said yes, it s their priority in teaching
english by using audio visual. Like what have been implemendted by teacher R6
below,
We use smartphone, because most of the
students already have smartphone so we (teachers and schools) asked them to
bring the smartphone to the school and open the link, link related to the topic
material like rumah belajar then from guruku then we take which topic that we
discussed at that day, the link itself we sent from Whatsapp because we have
class group chatroom for every single subject ( R6)
The students making video to practice their
speaking for instance making a dialoge related to the topic like greetings (R6)
R6 used the hardware smartphone to deliver the materials to students
and practicing student�s speaking by making a dialogue and record it. The video
that they have made submitted to teachers and teacher can help students to
correct their speech in fact, students realize their mistake in it they can
practice more to repeat their part. Next question is asking about existing
media provide more information than the one that teachers created. The results
show seven out of ten choose yes, it means teachers believe that existing media
can provide more information. The existing media here could be any sources like
youtube video, audio, blogs writing and many more, it is understandable if most
of teachers at junior high school in Sungai Penuh choose to adopt the existing
media because many sources from internet can provide more information to
deliver to students. Teachers at junior high schools in Sungai Penuh agreed
that using instructional media help students get better achievement in learning
English.
R8
said,
First of all, their
motivation of learning. They get motivated if we use visual media and they felt
curious about the topic then to check their understanding is more easier for me
and it is really good for students. They can remember the lesson that I taught
them in long time rather than I just explain the material from the text book.
(R8)
Using audio visual media are not just focus on what they see but also
they can listen to it and see the movements of it, it is interesting to them in
fact, they can remember what happend in the audio visual it self like video.
a.
Teacher�s view on instructional media
Table
4
Teacher�s
view towards audio visual instructional media
NO |
STATEMENTS |
TOTAL AVERAGE SCORE |
CLASSIFICATION |
1 |
The use of AV Instructional media is useful in teaching English |
3,6 |
Very good / positive |
2 |
The
use se of AV instructional media is useful in students' linguistic
activities. |
3,5 |
Very
good/ positive |
3 |
The use of AV instructional media is important for student�s outcome
in linguistic actevities. |
3,4 |
Very good/ positive |
4 |
The
audio instructional media below can be used by teachers in English teaching
activities: - Audio recordings (hints, stories, conversation) |
3,2 |
Good/positive |
|
- Audio drama |
2,6 |
Good/ positive |
|
- News reports |
2,7 |
Good/
positive |
|
- Song |
2,8 |
Good/positive |
5 |
The
visual instructional media below can be used by teachers in English teaching
activities: -
Picture |
3,4 |
Very
good/ positive |
|
- Flashcards |
2,9 |
Good/ positive |
|
-
Charts |
2,8 |
Good/positive |
6 |
The audio-visual instructional media below can be used by teacher in
English teaching activities: -Videos (documentaries, tutorials, teaching) |
3 |
Good/postive |
|
- Movies (audio drama, fairy tales, biographies) |
2,8 |
Good/positive |
|
- Television programs |
2,7 |
Good/positive |
7 |
AV
instructional media is a learning aid that interesting to use |
3,5 |
Very
good/ positive |
8 |
AV instructional media as a tool is crucial in teaching English |
3,4 |
Very good/ positive |
9 |
I
am more confident in teaching English when I use AV instructional media |
2,9 |
Good/positive |
10 |
I find it easier to deliver material lessons using AV instructional
media as intermediary. |
3 |
Good/ positive |
11 |
Learning
objectives are easier to achieved by using AV instructional media in teaching
and learning activities |
3 |
Good/positive |
12 |
Using AV instructional media in teaching and learning activities is
more practical than others media |
3 |
Good/ positive |
13 |
Students
responds faster when I use AV instructional media in delivering lesson |
3,1 |
Good/positive |
14 |
Students become more involved in using AV instructional media |
3,2 |
Good/positive |
15 |
Students
utilize the English language with more facility when using AV instructional
media |
3,3 |
Good/positive |
|
Average |
3 |
Good/positive |
Based on questionnaire results above, it is clear that most of the
teachers have good response toward the statements which is about their
experience adapting audio visual media in teaching English . Most of the
teachers agree to use audio visual as instructional media for assisting them in
teaching English. Most of them also totally agree that using audio visual media
is beneficial for studesnt learning process like what have presented from the
first statement, the score for this statement is 3,6 where 6 out of ten totally
agree with the statements. The next statement, which is statement number 2
stating that using audio visual instructional media is usufel for their
linguistics activities especially when it comes to the practice section like
speaking, listening, reading and writing. The score of this statement is� 3,5 where 5 respondents totally agree with
the statements. Next statement score is 3,4. This statement is stating that
audio visual instructional media is important for students outcome in
linguistics activities. It means that using audio visual in teaching help
students to get better outcome in linguistics aspects.
Discussion
Based
on the results, Teachers in this study adapting several instructional media to
assit them in teaching English. The instructional media can help teachers in
teaching activities. The media can contribute to the formation of abstract
concepts, that the use of appropriate media, improve the quality of learning
and teaching English (Winola, 2021). The media that teachers use
were variatif for different topics of the lesson. Adapting the instructional
media aimed to make better achievement and excitement for students. Teachers
who participated on this study generally have the same way in how they were
adapting the media.
Situation
and conditions of schools, teacher and students affect on how teachers adapt the
instructional media. In this study, teachers were facing new normal impact of
the Sars-Cov19 pandemic. The schools are partially open in Sungai Penuh around
September 2021 and fully open in January 2022, before that they had to deal
with online schools and shifted time of offline schools. Consequently, teachers
face significant challenges in adapting to online teaching, and maintaining at
least a minimum of communication with students and supporting students�
learning and development (Johannes, 2020). Teachers have to find a
way on how facing this problems and to make sure that students get the
knowledge even with minimum communication. That is why adapting instructional
is important.
Acoording
to the questionnaire and interview data, teachers were adapting the
instructional media through concrete object surround the schools and classroom.
Teachers claimed that by using media that they can found near to them it will
be effective and make students understand more about the context. Moreover,
concrete object are used as media because teachers does not have time to
prepare so they just use the things that they can grab on the spot. Learning
media can be created from any objects, it is the result of teachers�s
creativies in accordance with the material. The media can be created on any
subject matter by using any object, but the media can also be taken from
existing objects such as television, movies, pictures, tapes, and others. As
long as it can be matched with a subject matter that will be delivered (Tamrin, 2017).�
Another way adapting instructional media that researcher found from the
teachers are, teachers were utilizing the smartphone. students are allowed to
bring it to the schools during New normal. Teachers sent the assignment online
through Whatsapp app (Messangger aplication) or Google classroom and
communicate with the students in chattroom then asking students to create video
where they can practice their speaking skills by monologue and dialogue, then
they discussed the results of video in the class. Using video can affect
educational achievement in a positive way.
With
reference of the results finding, the researcher noticed that teachers were
struggling during online and transition to offline. Teachers believed that
using instructional media like audio visual media help them to get students
motivation back in learning but somehow it becomes the new problems for
teachers because they have limited time to prepare the material using audio
visual media. The highly used media by teachers in teaching were printed paper,
paper, whiteboard, pictures, song, video, and audio recording. Printed paper
itself categorized as textbook or coursebook that teachers mostly use to assist
them. Having media in their English class continuously can either make the
teachers have a good view or bad view toward media. As Nick (2006) asserts that
a view of a particular thing comes from the result of interpretation of facts.
Here, the teachers� themselves give their opinion about media based on the fact
that they experience while having the media in the classroom and during online
schools, and based on the facts that they got, the teachers reveal that they
have a good view of instructional media. Teachers agreed that audio visual
instructional media is attractive and increasing students motivation in
studying also it helps them to get good achievment.
CONCLUSION
The
data analysis results shows that the teachers at Junior High Schools in Sungai
Penuh used variatif instructional media in teaching. The researcher found that types
of audio visual instructional media that mostly used among the teachers to
improve student�s skills are audio recording (9,4)
(hints,stories,conversation)� and Videos
(8,4) (documentaries,tutorials,teaching) which is very good response. The most
used to improve speaking is Song (6,1) and Picture (7,3) teachers have good
response towards them. Next, for reading is picture (8,8) and last to improve
writing skills song (6,4), picture (6,8), flashcards (5,9), charts (5,7),
videos (5,1) also have good response. Audio drama, movies, TV programs, news
broadcast are the media that have bad response from teachers in other words,
teachers do not really used those media in teaching. Additionally, The most
used hardware among the teachers are whiteboard (9,7) printed paper (9,1),
smartphone (8,4), computer /laptop (7,7) . Radio, recorder, CD player are get
low response from the teachers.
In
adapting instructional media, teachers adapting from concrete object surround
the classroom and schools, teachers also utilze digital devices like smartphone
and software application like Whatsapp and Youtube. Moreover, teachers adapting
the existing media and combined with other media that created by their own to
assit them in delivering the materials.
In
addition, Teachers at five different junior high schools in Sungai Penuh have
good views towards instructional media, the results shows that most of the
teachers have good response that translated from questionnaire data.
REFERENCES
Aini, W. N. (2013). Instructional media in teaching English to young
learners: A case study in elementary schools in Kuningan. Journal of English and Education, 1(1), 196-205
Bishop, P. A., & Herron, R. L. (2015). Use
and misuse of the Likert item responses and other ordinal measures. International journal of exercise science,
8(3), 297.
Dardjowidjojo, S.
(2003b). English Policies and Their Classroom Impact in Some ASEAN/Asian
Countries.K.E. Sukamto (Ed), Rampai
Bahasa, Pendidikan, dan Budaya: Kumpulan Esai Soenjono Dardjowidjojo, 6382.
Jakarta:Yayasan Obor Indonesia.
Harmer, J. (2001). The Practice
of English Language Teaching (3rd ed.). Harlow: Longman.
Harman, K., &
Bich, N. T. N. (2010). Reforming teaching and learning in Vietnam�s higher
education system. In Reforming higher
education in Vietnam (pp. 65-86). Springer, Dordrecht.
Huda, N. (2000).
Kedudukan dan fungsi bahasa asing (The Position and Function of Foreign
Languages). In H. Alwi dan D. Sugono, Politik
Bahasa: RisalahSeminar Politik Bahasa (Language Politics: Procedingsof the
Seminar on Language Politics), 59-78. Jakarta:Pusat Bahasa dan Departemen
Pendidikan Nasional.
Johannes K�nig, Daniela J. J�ger-Biela & Nina
Glutsch (2020). Adapting to online teaching during COVID-19 school
closure: teacher education and teacher competence effects among early career
teachers in Germany.European Journal of
Teacher Education, 43:4, 608-622
Simatupang, M. (1999). Bahasa Inggris: Variasi Yang Mana? Suatu
Tinjauan Ulang Tentang Status Bahasa Inggris di Indonesia. In B.K. Purwo (Ed). PELLBA 12 (Pertemuan Linguistik Lembaga
Bahasa Atma Jaya: Kedua Belas), 63-84. Jakarta: Pusat Kajian dan Budaya
Unika Atma Jaya.
Renandya, W A. (2000). Indonesia. In Wah Kam Ho and Ruth Y. L. Wong
(Eds). Language Policies and Language Education: The Impact in East Asian
Countries in the Next Decade, eds. 113-137. Singapore: Times Academic Press.
McGhie-Richmond, D., & Sung, A. N. (2013). Applying Universal Design
for Learning to Instructional Lesson Planning. International Journal of Whole Schooling, 9(1), 43-59.
Tamrin, M & Azkiya, Hidayati & Sari,
Syafni. (2017). Problems Faced by the Teacher in Maximizing the Use of Learning
Media in Padang. Al-Ta lim Journal.
24. 60. 10.15548/jt. v24i1.262.
Copyright Holders:
Tiara Indah Sari, Surono, Estrella Arroyo (2022)
First publication right:
Devotion - Journal of Research and Community Service
This article is licensed under a Creative Commons
Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International